“…Despite many elegant investigations and much deeper interpretation on the nanopores or nanotubes have been reported in many famous journals [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11], until now, the driving force for the pore formation still remains unclear [4,5,12], because it is hardly derived by direct in-situ methods [11]. The generally accepted mechanism for the pore formation in anodic titania films is the field-assisted dissolution (or preferential oxide dissolution) process (equation (1)) [9,[12][13][14], which is similar to that in PAA films (equation (2)) [15][16][17], despite the lack of direct experimental evidence that confirms this expectation [16]. However, this important fact has been ignored for decades, and the reaction (1) has been cited extensively to explain the growth mechanism of ATNTs.…”