The synthesis of the classical, neutral donor–acceptor adducts Ph2MeP–/Ph3P–/Ph3As–Al(ORF)3 and H2O–Al(ORF)3 [1, 2, 3, 4, ORF = OC(CF3)3] is reported. The intermediate H2O–Al(ORF)3 (4) was generated by substitution of PhF in PhF–Al(ORF)3 with H2O and was analyzed in a long‐term NMR study over 22 days. This Brønsted acidic system was used in orienting experiments to protonate phosphanes such as PMePh2, PPh3, PCy3, P(tBu)3, and PCy2[2,4,6‐(iPr)3C6H2]. Depending on the use of one or two equivalents of PhF–Al(ORF)3, the new weakly coordinating anions [(RFO)3Al(μ‐OH)Al(ORF)3]– or [HOAl(ORF)3]– were obtained. However, in dependence of the steric bulk of the phosphanes, stable and unreactive R3P–Al(ORF)3 adducts were also observed in the NMR experiments. The absolute acidity of the key H2O–Al(ORF)3 adduct was evaluated by the relaxed COSMO cluster‐continuum (rCCC, COSMO = conductor‐like screening model) model in fluorobenzene solution. For a 0.001 M solution of H2O–Al(ORF)3, the medium acidity resulted as –986 kJ mol–1 or a pHabs value of 173. Long‐term hydrolysis of H2O–Al(ORF)3 (4), probably to give HORF and HOAl(ORF)2 followed by trimerization, gave [HOAl(ORF)2]3 (10), which was identified by X‐ray diffraction.