Self-criticism and self-esteem in early adolescence: Do they predict depression?

Abstract

Beck’s theory suggests that forming negative self-cognitions is a key early step in the development of depression. However, others have suggested the reverse, arguing that depression leads to development of negative self-beliefs. As such, there is debate about whether these cognitions are precursors to, or alternatively are caused by, depression. Although Beck’s theory is supported in older adolescents, it has not been clearly seen in younger adolescents. This study aimed to assess the relation between two major self-cognitions (self-esteem and self-criticism) and depressive symptoms in early adolescence. Two-hundred and forty-three Australian adolescents (mean age = 12.08, 52% female) completed measures of self-esteem, self-criticism and depressive symptoms at baseline, then approximately 12- and 24-months later. Growth-curve modelling was used to assess changes in the variables. Cross-lagged analysis assessed whether either of the self-cognition variables predicted depressive symptoms, or if depressive symptoms predicted self-cognitions. Results indicated that self-criticism and depressive symptoms increased over the time period, while self-esteem decreased, and these changes were all related. Self-esteem predicted depressive symptoms from Time 2 to Time 3, while depressive symptoms predicted self-esteem from Time 1 to Time 2. Self-criticism did not predict depressive symptoms, nor did depressive symptoms predict self-criticism. These links appeared largely independent of gender. Self-esteem and depressive symptoms during the early adolescent period thus appear to have a somewhat reciprocal relation, while self-criticism does not appear to predict the development of depression. As such, while low self-esteem does appear to have an important role of in the development of depression in this age group, it is not strictly predictive, nor is this effect seen across all negative self-cognitions.

Influence of Confinement Due to COVID-19 on Physical Activity and Mediterranean Diet Adherence and Its Relationship with Self-Esteem in Pre-Adolescent Students

“…In addition, SE students obtained significantly lower self-esteem scores than PE students. Research such as that conducted by Gittins and Hunt [78] found that self-esteem levels begin to drop from the age of 12. This occurs due to the emergence of self-criticism and self-evaluations of self-worth.…”

Impact of Childhood Maltreatment on Self-esteem among Adolescence at Zagazig City

“…Nonetheless, the multivariate analysis did not confirm the effect of age on self-esteem. In agreement with this age trend, a study among Australian adolescents showed that their self-esteem was decreasing with age (Gittins and Hunt,) (24) .…”

Conflictos de pareja y alimentación emocional: variables asociadas

“…No solo eso, sino que también se confirmó que las mujeres sentían las emociones negativas más intensamente que los hombres, por el mismo factor explicado anteriormente [30,45]. La última prevalencia en mujeres (vs. Hombres) en cuanto a las escalas fue la autocrítica, ya que las mujeres son más propensas ser duras y críticas consigo mismas y sus acciones [46]. La única variable que mostró mayores puntuaciones en hombres que en mujeres fue la retirada social, siendo ellos los más propensos a evitar la confrontación del conflicto como indica la literatura científica [13].…”