Self rating of health is associated with stressful life events, social support and residency in East and West Berlin shortly after the fall of the wall

Abstract

Study objective-To compare the health status and factors influencing the health of populations that had previously lived under diVerent political systems. Design-Cross sectional health and social survey using postal interviews. The relation between self reported health and psychosocial factors (stressful life events, social support, education, health promoting life style and health endangering behaviour) was investigated. To determine EastWest diVerences a logistic regression model including interaction terms was fitted. Setting-East and West Berlin shortly after reunification 1991. Participants-Representative sample of 4430 Berlin residents aged 18 years and over (response rate 63%).Results-Of all respondents, 15.4% rated their health as unsatisfactory. Residents of East Berlin rated their health more frequently as unsatisfactory than residents of West Berlin (Or age adjusted = 1.29, 95%CI 1.08, 1.52), these diVerences occurred predominantly in the over 60 years age group. Logistic regression showed significant independent eVects of stressful life events, social support, education, and health promoting life style on self rated health. The eVects of education and health promoting life style were observed to be more pronounced in the western part of Berlin. Old age and female sex showed a stronger association with unsatisfactory health status in the eastern part of Berlin. Conclusions-For subjects aged over 60 years there was evidence that living in the former East Berlin had an adverse eVect on health compared with West Berlin. The impact of education and a health promoting lifestyle on self rated health seemed to be weaker in a former socialist society compared with that of a Western democracy. This study supports an "additive model" rather than a "buVering model" in explaining the eVects of psychosocial factors on health. (J Epidemiol Community Health 2000;54:575-580)

Differences in self-rated health among older adults according to socioeconomic circumstances: the Bambuí Health and Aging Study

“…In general, the results of the present study confirm (in one or both of the socioeconomic groups studied) previous observations of the existence of association between self-rated health and socioeconomic circumstances 5,6,7,8 , social network 1 , medical conditions 4,26 , access to health services 27 , and physician visits and hospitalizations 28 . Associations between lifestyle risk factors and self-rated health have been observed in some studies 29 , but not in all 30 . In the present study, none of the lifestyle risk factors was independently associated with selfrated health in either group.…”

“…This result is consistent with the absence of association between self-rated health and the metabolic syndrome observed in this study and with previous observations of the absence of association between self-rated health and coronary risk profile 31 . The absence of association between self-rated health and negative lifestyle habits, as previously emphasized 30 , must be considered in planning and evaluating preventive programs based on behavior changes.…”

Does morbidity matter? Perceived health status in explaining the share of healthcare expenditures

“…They are also less likely to be absent from work due to illness. 3 See McGee et al (1999), Burstrom and Fredlund (2001), Heistaro et al (2001) and Hillen et al (2000) for the positive relationship between self-rated and actual health outcomes.…”

Using Australian DRGs in Germany:a commentary

“…The jury is still out regarding cost-effectiveness. However, the latest studies suggest that, if there was any difference in health status, it might marginally have favoured the West among the elderly (Hillen et al, 2000). Aspects of both systems might have been included in a better model, but there was too little time and so much else to do.It is rarely the case in health care that, if one puts aside fundamental conflicts of choice, they will disappear in time.…”