Self-reported priorities and resources of academic emergency physicians for the maintenance of clinical competence: a pilot study

Abstract

Objectives: Medical licensing bodies and professional colleges require their members to maintain a broad spectrum of knowledge, skills and attitudes, which, when taken together, define a competent emergency physician (EP). The objectives of this pilot study were: 1) to determine the resources used by academic EPs to maintain competence and 2) to determine academic EPs' learning priorities. Methods: Using a modified Dillman method, we surveyed EPs from 2 Canadian academic tertiary health sciences centres. Results: Thirty-seven (68.5%) of 54 EPs responded. Of those responding, 14 (37.8%) attended grand rounds 3 times or more annually, and 34 (91.7%) attended a medical conference or course at least once annually. Thirty-three (89.2%) respondents read journal articles at least once monthly, with 22 (59.5%) of those reading synopses of original articles. Twenty-three (62.1%) received clinical updates via email, and 11 (29.7%) subscribed to an audio journal or podcast of reviews of original research. Among the CanMEDS roles, Medical Expert, Scholar and Manager were selected as top professional development priorities by more than one-third of respondents. The topics that were not selected as priorities by respondents included patient communication and charting (Communicator); conflict resolution skills and teamwork abilities (Collaborator); advocate for patient and promote health in emergency department populations (Health Advocate) and ethical conflict resolution (Professional). Conclusion:The results of this pilot study suggest that in order to maintain clinical competence in emergency medicine, traditional formats of professional development (e.g., grand rounds, print media and original research) are being substituted for independent study, online media and reviews of original research. This study also suggests a strong preference for Medical Expert topics, while Professional, Health Advocate, Collaborator and Communicator topics are not a reported priority for professional development. RÉSUMÉObjectifs : Les instances responsables de la délivrance des permis d'exercice de la médecine et les collèges professionnels exigent que leurs membres maintiennent une vaste gamme de connaissances, d'aptitudes et d'attitudes qui, ensemble, définissent les compétences en médecine d'urgence. Les objectifs de cette étude pilote étaient de 1) déterminer les ressources utilisées par les médecins d'urgence en milieu universitaire pour le maintien de leurs compétences et 2) déterminer leurs priorités en matière d'apprentissage. Méthode : On a utilisé une version modifiée de la méthode Dillman pour interroger des médecins d'urgence de 2 centres hospitaliers universitaires de soins tertiaires. Résultats : Trente-sept (68,5 %) médecins d'urgence sur 54 ont répondu. Parmi les répondants, 14 (37,8 %) ont dit participer à des conférences scientifiques 3 fois l'an ou plus, et 34 (91,7 %) ont participé à une conférence ou à une séance de formation médicale au moins une fois l'an. Trente-trois (89,2 %) des répondants ont affirmé lire de...

‘Registrar in charge shifts’: Learning how to run a busy emergency department

“…A comprehensive learning needs analysis of Australasian emergency physicians highlighted that day‐to‐day departmental management and administration might be a source of considerable frustration, and was identified as a highly desirable topic for continuing medical education . A survey of Canadian emergency physicians also demonstrated a need for education in aspects of the Manager role, including patient flow strategies …”

“…19 A survey of Canadian emergency physicians also demonstrated a need for education in aspects of the Manager role, including patient flow strategies. 20 There is an increasing recognition by academic bodies of the need to explicitly address this aspect of training. The UK college of emergency medicine provides detailed outlines of competencies for 'time management and decision making', 'decision making and clinical reasoning', 'team working and patient safety' and 'communication with colleagues and cooperation'.…”

The importance of health advocacy in Canadian postgraduate medical education: current attitudes and issues

“… 22 Another study of academic emergency physicians showed health advocacy was not a priority for professional development. 23 This reduced priority is of paramount importance as it sheds some light on the issues being encountered by learners in this area. If faculty members are adamant that understanding and teaching advocacy is a challenge but improving instruction in this field is not a priority it creates a real problem for education surrounding the Health Advocate role.…”

Validity and reliability of an in-training evaluation report to measure the CanMEDS roles in emergency medicine residents

“…They are often the initial point of contact for patients entering the hospital system and are at an advantage to identify and act on the social, environmental, and biologic factors that influence the health of individuals and society. 11 It is important to measure clinical competence in EM residents to ensure that resident training program curricula are providing material and encounters for all aspects of clinical care. Although there has been research on the strengths and weaknesses of the different types of assessment tools, 12 at present, there is no literature on how Canadian residency programs effectively teach and assess their residents' clinical competencies in EM across all seven domains.…”