Self-reporting and measurement of body mass index in adolescents: refusals and validity, and the possible role of socioeconomic and health-related factors

Abstract

BackgroundBody mass index assessment using self-reported height and weight (BMIsr) can encounter refusals and under/over-reporting while for assessment with measured data (BMIm) refusals can be more frequent. This could relate to socioeconomic and health-related factors. We explored these issues by investigating numerous potential factors: gender, age, family structure, father’s occupation, income, physical/sports activity, subjective weight perception, school performance, unhealthy behaviours, physical/psychological health, social relationships, living environment, having sustained violence, sexual abuse, and involvement in violence.MethodsThe sample included 1559 adolescents from middle schools in north-eastern France. They completed a questionnaire including socioeconomic and health-related data, self-reported height/weight, measured height/weight, and weight perception (participation rate 94%). Data were analysed using logistic regression models.ResultsBMIsr encountered under-reporting (with change in BMI category, 11.8%), over-reporting (6.0%), and reporting refusals (3.6%). BMIm encountered more numerous refusals (7.9%). Reporting refusal was related to living with a single parent, low school performance, lack of physical/sports activity, sustained violence, poor psychological health, and poor social relationships (gender/age-adjusted odds ratios 1.95 to 2.91). Further to these factors, measurement refusal was related to older age, having divorced/separated parents, a father being a manual worker/inactive, insufficient family income, tobacco/cannabis use, involvement in violence, poor physical health, and poor living environment (1.30 to 3.68). Under-reporting was related to male gender, involvement in violence, poor psychological health, and overweight/obesity (as assessed with BMIm) (1.52 to 11). Over-reporting was related to male gender, younger age, alcohol consumption, and underweight (1.30 to 5.35). Weight perception was linked to reporting refusals and under/over-reporting, but slightly linked to measurement refusal. The contributions of socioeconomic and health-related factors to the associations of weight perception with reporting refusal and under/over-reporting ranged from −82% to 44%. There were substantial discrepancies in the associations between socioeconomic/health-related factors and overweight/obesity assessed with BMIsr and BMIm.ConclusionsBMIsr and BMIm were affected by numerous biases related to vulnerability which were also obesity risk factors. BMIsr encountered under/over-reporting which were related to some socioeconomic and health-related factors, weight perception, and BMIm. BMIm was more affected by refusals than BMIsr due to socioeconomic and health-related factors. Further research is needed.

Risk factors for diabetes are higher among non-heterosexual US high-school students

“…The study found that no differences in mischievous responses for bullying, feeling sad, watching television, or PA were detected by sex and sexual identity; BMI and playing video games were not assessed . Differences in reporting accuracy for BMI, however, have been reported by race and sex . The validity of self‐reported PA among adolescents has also been called into question: in the 2003‐2004 NHANES dataset, only 8% of adolescents 12 to 19 whose PA was assessed by accelerometer were found to meet guidelines, while 51% self‐reported PA levels that could be interpreted to meet guidelines .…”

“…37 Differences in reporting accuracy for BMI, however, have been reported by race 38 and sex. 39 The validity of self-reported PA among adolescents has also been called into question 40 : in the 2003-2004 NHANES dataset, only 8% of adolescents 12 to 19 whose PA was assessed by accelerometer were found to meet guidelines, while 51% self-reported PA levels that could be interpreted to meet guidelines. 41 The low overall rate of PA reported among students in this sample indicates that there is not much room for PA levels to decrease.…”

Accuracy of self-reported BMI using objective measurement in high school students

“…Self-reported data may provide an understanding of adolescent obesity, its correlates, precursors and impacts (16) . Though there is research on the relationship between self-reported and objectively measured height and weight in some adolescent populations, the evidence is not necessarily generalisable to the USA as most recent studies have been conducted outside of the USA or were conducted in one isolated location in the USA (18)(19)(20)(21)(22) .…”

Association Between Health-Related Quality of Life and Being an Immigrant Among Adolescents, and the Role of Socioeconomic and Health-Related Difficulties

“…Indeed, it is well known that unhealthy behaviors and violence are common among adolescents, and, because they are associated with socioeconomic difficulties [1,2,3,4,5], they may be more common among European and non-European immigrants. Tobacco and alcohol consumption affect physical, psychomotor and cognitive performance [26,27,28,29], cannabis use may exacerbate mental health difficulties [30], and early use is associated with a higher risk of suicidal behaviors [3].…”