“…Based on the above discussion in sections 4.1 and 4.2, we suggest that, at least in the Gale crater, MnO 2 precipitated from Mn 2+ -bearing reducing groundwater (e.g., Eh~0 V) by an interaction with high-Eh oxidants (e.g., Eh > 0. Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets acids and nitrates accumulated on the surface (Lasne et al, 2016;Smith et al, 2014), ice melting upon transient warming (e.g., Bishop et al, 2018;Kite et al, 2017;Wordsworth et al, 2017) could have provided a quantity of these oxidants to the subsurface (Fukushi et al, 2018). Given the Cl contents of the Mn enrichments (0.4-3.3 wt.%), nevertheless, the measured MnO 2 (3.7-6.0 wt.%) may not be generated solely by reactions of Mn 2+ with perchloric acids (Lanza et al, 2016).…”