Serial electron crystallography: merging diffraction data through rank aggregation

Abstract

Serial electron crystallography is being developed as an alternative way to collect diffraction data on beam-sensitive polycrystalline materials. Merging serial diffraction data from a large number of snapshots is difficult, and the dynamical nature of electron diffraction prevents the use of existing methods that rely on precise measurement of kinematical reflection intensities. To overcome this problem, an alternative method that uses rank aggregation to combine the rankings of relative reflection intensities from a large number of snapshots has been developed. The method does not attempt to accurately model the diffraction intensity, but instead optimizes the most likely ranking of reflections. As a consequence, the problem of scaling individual snapshots is avoided entirely, and requirements for the data quality and precision are low. The method works best when reflections can be fully measured, but the benefit over measuring partial intensities is small. Since there were no experimental data available for testing rank-based merging, the validity of the approach was assessed through a series of simulated serial electron diffraction datasets with different numbers of frames and varying degrees of errors. Several programs have been used to show that these rank-merged simulated data are good enough for ab initio structure determination using several direct methods programs.

Visualizing drug binding interactions using microcrystal electron diffraction

“…In addition, working with protein microcrystals may have several advantages, such as less sample material required and fast diffusion of ligand. We anticipate that with future hardware and software development optimized toward automated and high-throughput data collection and processing 35 , 39 , 40 , MicroED can become even more competitive with the ease and speed of synchrotron data collection and fragment screening.…”

Macromolecular crystallography using microcrystal electron diffraction

“…The same principle as in SFX can also be applied in TEM as serial electron diffraction (SerialED; Smeets et al, 2018;Bü cker et al, 2020). Using SerialED, a single electron diffraction pattern can be taken from one crystal in a single exposure (Smeets & Wan, 2017;Wang et al, 2019). Alternatively, dose-fractioning can be used (Bü cker et al, 2020).…”

Structure solution and refinement of metal-ion battery cathode materials using electron diffraction tomography

“…Fortunately, unlike data for electron tomography (direct space 3D object reconstruction through the series of projected images), for electron diffraction tomography, datasets from two or more different crystallites can be combined together, if necessary. For structure solution, only ranking of the intensities is required (Klein & David, 2011;Eggeman & Midgley, 2012), which allows structures to be solved even from snapshots of random crystals, avoiding the scaling completely by using rank aggregation to optimize the most likely reflection ranking (Smeets & Wan, 2017). For the subsequent refinement, on the other hand, high-quality intensities are necessary.…”