Setting Priorities to Inform Assessment of Care Homes’ Readiness to Participate in Healthcare Innovation: A Systematic Mapping Review and Consensus Process

Abstract

Organisational context is known to impact on the successful implementation of healthcare initiatives in care homes. We undertook a systematic mapping review to examine whether researchers have considered organisational context when planning, conducting, and reporting the implementation of healthcare innovations in care homes. Review data were mapped against the Alberta Context Tool, which was designed to assess organizational context in care homes. The review included 56 papers. No studies involved a systematic assessment of organisational context prior to implementation, but many provided post hoc explanations of how organisational context affected the success or otherwise of the innovation. Factors identified to explain a lack of success included poor senior staff engagement, non-alignment with care home culture, limited staff capacity to engage, and low levels of participation from health professionals such as general practitioners (GPs). Thirty-five stakeholders participated in workshops to discuss findings and develop questions for assessing care home readiness to participate in innovations. Ten questions were developed to initiate conversations between innovators and care home staff to support research and implementation. This framework can help researchers initiate discussions about health-related innovation. This will begin to address the gap between implementation theory and practice.

A complex intervention to reduce avoidable hospital admissions in nursing homes: a research programme including the BHiRCH-NH pilot cluster RCT

“…84 This includes assessing care home readiness and capacity to engage, including releasing all levels of staff to engage in intervention design. 143…”

The Effect of Providing Staff Training and Enhanced Support to Care Homes on Care Processes, Safety Climate and Avoidable Harms: Evaluation of a Care Home Quality Improvement Programme in England

“…SPACE also focused on facilitating positive changes to working culture by applying approaches that emphasised the role of leadership, capacity building and sharing of best practices. The co-design element of programme activities between facilitators and care home staff was reported as particularly important, and has been noted by others as a key means of embedding QI within organisations where active engagement from managers and staff is required for practice changes to be implemented [ 38 , 40 , 41 ]. Indeed, the influence of care home leadership on QI is often cited in the patient safety literature [ 42 ], and other similar programmes have found managerial leadership and care home capacity to engage with QI to be important influences on uptake and involvement [ 19 ].…”

Pilot Study to Develop and Test Palliative Care Quality Indicators for Nursing Homes

“…In this pilot study, we found the same barriers and facilitators pointing out the importance of setting the right preconditions for implementation in the nursing home context, throughout research and policy. This might be done by primordially evaluating nursing home readiness in order to increase the use and correct application of the quality indicators [ 55 ].…”