Sex‐based Disparities Among Surgical Faculty Positions Across Medical Colleges in Pakistan

Abstract

Introduction Despite women being under-represented in academic surgery, there is no publicly accessible repository describing the distribution of surgeons by sex and specialty in Pakistan. This short report aims to fulfill this gap by describing female representation across surgical faculty positions in medical colleges across Pakistan. Methods This cross-sectional study was conducted in 2021 across medical universities in Pakistan. A dual mode of data collection was employed, whereby data regarding sex, academic designation, and subspecialty of surgical faculty was retrieved via emails to representative faculty from medical colleges, and from medical colleges’ websites. Results A total of 97/114 (85.1%) medical colleges across Pakistan were included, providing us with data of 2070 surgical faculty. Overall, only 10.3% of surgical faculty were women, with women comprising 14.1% of assistant professors, 9.3% of associate professors, and only 5.7% of professors. Most women surgical faculty were assistant professors (63.1%), with only 17.8% being professors. Sindh (14.3%) and Punjab (9.7%) had the greatest percentage of women across surgical faculty overall, while Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had the lowest (6.5%). Apart from breast surgery (100%), pediatric surgery (29.4%), ophthalmology (15.0%) and general surgery (11.6%), women did not represent more than 10% of surgical faculty for any surgical subspecialty. Conclusion In Pakistan, there is a blatant lack of female representation across all faculty positions and in most surgical specialties, with imbalances more pronounced in the relatively under-developed Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. These sex disparities may aggravate the surgical disease burden and adversely impact surgical prospects for women across the country.

Rates of breast reconstruction uptake and attitudes toward breast cancer and survivorship among south asians: A literature review

“…Another cultural aspect affecting breast reconstruction frequency is discomfort discussing breast health or reconstruction with oncologists 35 and plastic surgeons who are overwhelmingly male. In one study conducted among plastic surgeons in India, only 11.2% (37/330) were female, 42 and in a survey of surgical faculty at medical colleges in Pakistan, 9.4% of plastic surgeon respondents were women (5/53) (statistics on surgeon demographic in other South Asian countries were unable to be found) 43 . While this is only a sample of surgeons in those countries, these ratios are more skewed male than the 5:1 male:female plastic surgeon ratio in the United States 44 .…”

“…(37/330) were female, 42 and in a survey of surgical faculty at medical colleges in Pakistan, 9.4% of plastic surgeon respondents were women (5/53) (statistics on surgeon demographic in other South Asian countries were unable to be found). 43 While this is only a sample of surgeons in those countries, these ratios are more skewed male than the 5:1 male:female plastic surgeon ratio in the United States. 44 To minimize their time and exposure to the predominately male reconstructive surgeons, they may only agree to the bare minimum treatment.…”

Global Access to Comprehensive Care for Paediatric and Congenital Heart Disease

“…For example, only 6% of cardiothoracic surgeons in the United States and 11% of cardiovascular surgeons in Canada are women. 19 In Pakistan, less than 2% of cardiothoracic surgical faculty are women, 20 whereas data from other LMICs are limited but anecdotally comparable. Data on the global cardiology workforce are scarce, although some estimates exist.…”

Survival in general surgery: The female surgeons’ perspective

“…This disparity is more pronounced in provinces like Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan with only 24(6.5%) and 7(3.1%) practicing female surgeons respectively thus suggesting an impact of culture as well. 5 According to Human Resources for Health Observer Series No. 24. the main reasons of inequalities are gender biased working environments, discrimination and harassment including sexual harassment, gender pay gap and gender disparity in leadership.…”

“…This disparity is more pronounced in provinces like Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan with only 24(6.5%) and 7(3.1%) practicing female surgeons respectively thus suggesting an impact of culture as well. 5 …”