Recently, much attention has been focused on a group of rhabditid nematodes calledPhasmarhabditis, a junior synonym ofPellioditis, as a promising source of biocontrol agents for invasive slugs.Pellioditis pelhamin. sp. was first isolated from earthworms near Pelham Bay Park in Bronx, New York, USA, in 1990, and has been found to be pathogenic to slugs as well as some earthworms. It has also been used in several comparative developmental studies. Here, we provide a description of this species, as well as a redescription of a similar earthworm-associated nematode,Pellioditis pellioSchneider, 1866, re-isolated from the type locality. AlthoughP. pelhamin. sp. andP. pellioare morphologically similar, they are reproductively isolated. Molecular phylogenetic analysis places both species in a clade that includes all species previously described asPhasmarhabditiswhich are associated with gastropods.PhasmarhabditisAndrássy, 1976 is therefore a junior synonym ofPellioditisDougherty, 1953. Also,Phasmarhabditis bohemicaNermut', Půža, Mekete & Mráček, 2017, described to be a facultative parasite of slugs, is found to be a junior synonym ofPellioditis pellio(Schneider, 1866), adding to evidence thatP. pelliois associated with both slugs and earthworms. The earthworm-associated speciesP. pelhamin. sp. andP. pelliorepresent different subclades withinPellioditis, suggesting thatPellioditisspecies in general have a broader host range than just slugs. Because of this, caution is warranted in using these species as biological control agents until more is understood about their ecology.