Sexual Dimorphism in Skates (Rajidae) and Its Possible Role in Differential Niche Utilization

Abstract

Adaptive radiation has been thought of generally as evolutionary divergence of species or higher taxonomic categories into differing zones or niches. Evidence is now accumulating to indicate that a lesser degree of adaptive radiation may also occur within animal populations, so that individuals may came to occupy different subniches or subzones (see Selander, 1966 and1969, for a more complete discussion of this topic). When individuals within a population come to occupy differing subniches or adaptive subzones, the total niche of the species may be partitioned or even expanded in cases where the environmental situation will allow. Thus in many organisms sexual dimorphism may arise and result in a differential niche utilization by the sexes, which in turn may result in decreased intraspecific competition for food,The role of sexual dimorphism in birds as an adaptive agent in the reduction of intraspecific competition has been extensively reviewed and discussed by Selander (1966), and more recently additional data have been added by many authors. 'These are primarily cases in which morphological differences in the bill length between males and females indicates differences in foraging pre.ferences between the sexes. Selander (1966) also suggested that behavioral polymorphism expressed as sexually dimorphic behavior could operate without concomitant modification of the feeding apparatus. This has been recently confirmed by Morse (1968) for wood warblers, Williamson (1971) for vireos, and Robins (1971) for a grassland sparrow. In these cases there were differences in foraging pre.ferences between the sexes without expressed morphological differences in bill length.Birds have provided almost all of the examples of differential niche utilization by the sexes, primarily because foraging behavior is for the most part diurnal and easily observed. However, sexual differences which correlate with differences in foraging behavior have been recorded for several species of fresh-water fishes by Keast (1966), and for Anolis lizards by Schoener (1967, 1968).Sexual dimorphism in the feeding apparatus of skates has often been noted but almost no evi--dence concerning the significance of this phenomenon has been presented. Perhaps the most in-triguing aspect of this phenomenon is that all skates (for which we have information) can be sorted roughly into three categories (Fig. 1): 1) essentially non-dimorphic, in which both sexes have pointed teeth adapted for grasping and tearing rather active prey j 2) dimorphic species in which teeth not brought into use are pointed, but the points are retained in the males while those in the females are quickly reduced to grinding buttons j and 3) dimorphic species in which the grinding character of the female dentition is genetically fixed and not just produced by wear.The purpose of this paper is to consider the possibility that the strongly dimorphic feeding apparatus in many skates represents another example of differential niche utilization by the sexes. DEPTH RANGESNo elaborate statistical...

Sexual dimorphism in the feeding mechanism of threespine stickleback

“…Sexual dimorphism in trophic structures is known in several fish groups (Feduccia and Slaughter, 1974;Barnett and Bellwood, 2005;Albert and Crampton, 2009;Hoey et al, 2012) and is suspected in others, but our findings are the first to demonstrate sexual dimorphism in feeding kinematics. It is particularly interesting that one of the major differences between male and female stickleback is in jaw protrusion, a trait that has long been thought to impact various aspects of feeding ability (Schaeffer and Rosen, 1961;Motta, 1984) and was recently shown to play a major role in determining suction-feeding performance (Holzman et al, 2008;Holzman et al, 2012).…”

Functional implications of ontogenetic and sexual dimorphic dentition in the eastern shovelnose ray Aptychotrema rostrata (Shaw & Nodder, 1794)

“…These include both morphological characters, such as total length (Last and Stevens, 2009;Orlov and Cotton, 2011) and head shape (Ellis and Shackley, 1995;Filiz and Taskavak, 2006), and sensory biology characters, such as development of the ampullae of Lorenzini (Crooks and Waring, 2013). Within the batoid fishes (skates, rays and guitarfishes), a known sexual dimorphism occurs in dentition, as males of many species, in contrast to females, develop highly cuspidate teeth as they mature (Feduccia and Slaughter, 1974;Kajiura and Tricas, 1996;Powter et al, 2010;Taniuchi and Shimizu, 1993).…”

“…Initially, it was thought that sexually dimorphic dentition was due to the sexes occupying different niches and targeting different prey (Feduccia and Slaughter, 1974). However, support for this hypothesis is lacking, as data from four species of rajids that exhibited sexually dimorphic dentition showed no significant difference between the diets of mature males and females (Lyle, 1983;McEachran, 1977;Taniuchi and Shimizu, 1993).…”

Trophic radiation through polymorphism in cichlid fishes

“…Sexual dimorphism associated with trophic diversification has been abundantly documented in vertebrates (22)(23)(24)(25), but apparently the only previous consideration of non-sexual trophic polymorphism is that of Roberts (26), who suggested that five taxonomic species of freshwater fishes of the genus Saccodon, also based on dentition, are morphs. The demonstration of trophic polymorphism in the Cuatro Cienegas cichlids has immediate importance with respect to evolutionary interpretations of the extensive and well known morphological differentiation and trophic radiation of cichlids in the rift valley and other lakes in Africa (4).…”