Prompted by queries on the potential mechanism for the inverse sensitivity of the biosensing assay reported in the published Letter, as well as about the protocols that we used to obtain the results, here we provide extended discussion of the signal-generation mechanism as well as additional methodological details.
Signal-generation mechanismAs described in the published Letter, the signal is generated by the reduction of silver ions on gold nanostars. The reduction of silver triggers a shift in the localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) of the dispersed gold nanostars (which act as sensors). The reduction of silver on the gold nanostars is known to be affected by the following factors:(i) The concentration of hydrogen peroxide generated by glucose oxidase (GOx), which can reduce silver ions . The reduction of silver ions on gold nanoparticles can also be affected by the presence of PVP because PVP can selectively adsorb silver nanostructures. Indeed, in gold-silver core-shell nanoparticles with cubic, triangularbipyramidal, and rod or wire silver shells, {100}-type dominant facets were formed upon epitaxial growth on the {111}-type facets of the gold core 10,11 . The morphology change between the Au core and Ag shells may have its origin in the change of adsorption selectivity of PVP molecules from Au{111}-type facets to Ag{100}-type ones in ethylene glycol solvent. Such selective adsorption of PVP molecules can also affect the growth rate of the adsorbed Ag facets. Finally, it should be noted that the PVP around the nanostars may play a crucial role in other processes not related to the growth of silver nanoparticles. For example, the reshaping of nanostars depends on the concentration of PVP around them 12 . Moreover, different batches of nanostars may have slightly different LSPRs, owing to slightly different concentrations of PVP around these colloids. Since the concentration of PVP around the nanostars depends on the number of washing steps to which the nanostars are subjected, the LSPR of the nanostars may also change depending on the number of intermediate steps preceding the silver reduction on the nanostars. For all these reasons, we reported changes in the LSPR of the nanostars resulting from the reduction of silver ions on gold as a shift with respect to a blank experiment performed in the same conditions and with nanostars obtained from the same batch.(vii) The presence of unreacted aldehyde groups around the nanostars. Aldehydes have been previously used to reduce metal ions on nanoparticle seeds 13 . Unreacted aldehyde groups did not affect the reported data (Fig. 4) because they were blocked with bovine serum albumin (BSA) and ethanolamine to avoid non-specific interactions in the immunoassay. However, aldehyde groups were not blocked in the experiments shown in Fig. 2c, because no biorecognition experiments were performed with the nanostars bearing covalently bound GOx.Our experiments were performed in excess of glucose, MES and light. We observed that the reaction did not take place (to an ...