“She” and “He” in News Media Messages: Pronoun Use Reflects Gender Biases in Semantic Contexts

Abstract

Previous research has shown a male bias in the media. This study tests this statement by examining how the pronouns She and He are used in a news media context. More specifically, the study tests whether He occurs more often and in more positive semantic contexts than She, as well as whether She is associated with more stereotypically and essential labels than He is. Latent semantic analysis (LSA) was applied to 400 000 Reuters' news messages, written in English, published in 1996-1997. LSA is a completely data-driven method, extracting statistics of words from how they are used throughout a corpus. As such, no human coders are involved in the assessment of how pronouns occur in their contexts. The results showed that He pronouns were about 9 times more frequent than She pronouns. In addition, the semantic contexts of He were more positive than the contexts of She. Moreover, words associated with She-contexts included more words denoting gender, and were more homogeneous than the words associated with He-contexts. Altogether, these results indicate that men are represented as the norm in these media. Since these news messages are distributed on a daily basis all over the world, in printed newspapers, and on the internet, it seems likely that this presentation maintains, and reinforces prevalent gender stereotypes, hence contributing to gender inequities.

Of Caring Nurses and Assertive Police Officers: Social Role Information Overrides Gender Stereotypes in Linguistic Behavior

“…Altogether, participants reproduced gender stereotype content by combining female-dominated occupations more often with communal than agentic traits and male-dominated occupations more often with agentic than communal traits (Studies 1 through 3), female-definitional nouns/pronouns more often with communal than agentic traits, and male-definitional nouns/pronouns more often with agentic than communal traits (Studies 1 and 2). These findings are consistent with research showing that women and men were presented gender stereotypically in the media (Gustafsson Sendén, Sikström, & Lindholm, 2015; Lauzen, Dozier, & Horan, 2008; Matud, Rodrigez, & Espinosa, 2011; Signorielli & Kahlenberg, 2001) and in recommendation letters (Madera, Hebl, & Martin, 2009). Also, experimental studies have found that female- or male-dominated occupations increased the accessibility of gender-stereotypically congruent pronouns and traits (Blair & Banaji, 1996; Kreiner, Sturt, & Garrod, 2008).…”

The big two dictionaries: Capturing agency and communion in natural language

“…Recently, text analysis started to play a significant role in psychological research (e.g., Eichstaedt et al, 2015;Gustafsson Send en et al, 2014;Mooijman, Hoover, Lin, Ji, & Dehghani, 2018;Van Swol & Kane, 2018), for instance, in reliably evaluating an individual's personality, status, or mood just based on the use of pronouns (see Campbell & Pennebaker, 2003;Pennebaker, 2011). Thus, analyzing 400,000 articles (a dataset released by Reuters for research and the development of natural language processing) would take 400,000 hours, which would require 200 full-time coders working for a year if every article were analyzed for an hour (based on 2,000 working hours per year; for details see Gustafsson Send en, Sikstr€ om, & Lindholm, 2015). As such, our work facilitates the study of agency and communion in more accessible and sizable datasets (e.g.…”

Arabic Mass Media and Women Gender Stereotype: Stability versus Change “The Dream of Women Empowerment”

“…Moreover, words associated with She-contexts included more words denoting gender, and were more homogeneous than the words associated with He-contexts. Altogether, these results indicate that men are represented as the norm in these media [17].…”