Shear-Thinning and Temperature-Dependent Viscosity Relationships of Contemporary Ocular Lubricants

Abstract

Purpose To evaluate the shear viscosity of contemporary, commercially available ocular lubricants at various shear rates and temperatures and to derive relevant mathematical viscosity models that are impactful for prescribing and developing eye drops to treat dry eye disease. Methods The shear viscosity of 12 ocular lubricants was measured using a rheometer and a temperature-controlled bath at clinically relevant temperatures at which users may experience exposure to the drops (out of the refrigerator [4.3°C]; room temperature [24.6°C]; ocular surface temperature [34.5°C]). Three replicates for each sample at each temperature were obtained using a standard volume (0.5 mL) of each sample. The viscosity of each ocular lubricant was measured over the full range of shear rates allowed by the rheometer. Results The shear viscosity of the same ocular lubricant varied significantly among the three temperatures. In general, a higher temperature resulted in smaller viscosities than a lower temperature (an average of −48% relative change from 4.3°C to 24.6°C and −21% from 24.6°C to 34.5°C). At a constant temperature, the viscosity of an ocular lubricant over the studied shear rates can be well approximated by a power-law model. Conclusions Rheological analysis revealed that the ocular lubricants exhibited shear-thinning behavior at the measured temperatures. Differences in the ocular lubricants’ formulations and measured temperatures resulted in different viscosities. Translational Relevance When prescribing eye drops, eye care professionals can select the optimal one for their patients by considering a variety of factors, including its rheological property at physiologically relevant shear rates and temperatures, which can improve residence time on the ocular surface, while ensuring appropriate comfort and vision. However, care must be taken when using the derived mathematical models in this study because the in vivo shear behavior of the ocular lubricants has not been examined and might show deviations from those reported when placed on the ocular surface.

Evaluating Viscosity and Tear Breakup Time of Contemporary Commercial Ocular Lubricants on an In Vitro Eye Model

“…For most of the lubricants tested, increasing the angular frequencies was correlated with a reduction in viscosity, indicating the formulations have shear-thinning properties. 29 , 30 This study also showed that there were significant differences in the complex viscosities of the various commercial lubricants tested, which also corresponded to differences in NIKBUT. Overall, the NIKBUT data suggest that almost all formulations performed better than the control (without any lubricants) and PBS instillation.…”

Evaluation of Non-Cross Linked Xeno-Free Hyaluronic Acid Solutions as Visco Elastic Biomaterials

“…On the other hand, they also maintain low viscosity at high shear rates, which gives better ocular comfort as well as prevents friction-related inflammation issues. [ 10 , 11 ]…”

A comparison between hyaluronic acid and other single ingredient eye drops for dry eye, a review

“…Drop frequency should be tailored to the individual DED patient (Kim et al, 2021). Considering the huge variability in ingredients, concentrations, viscosity and other characteristics among the various products available (Kapadia et al, 2022), drop frequency should also depend on the specific product used. The heterogeneity in drop frequency across studies can be attributed to the lack of studies specifically investigating this aspect of DED treatment, as exemplified by a literature review of HA treatment for DED by our group that describes this literature gap (Hynnekleiv et al), as well as the current review in which no such studies were found.…”