Shift in power during an interview situation: methodological reflections inspired by Foucault and Bourdieu

Abstract

This paper presents methodological reflections on power sharing and shifts of power in various interview situations. Narratives are said to be shaped by our attempts to position ourselves within social and cultural circumstances. In an interview situation, power can be seen as something that is created and that shifts between the interviewer and the interviewed. Reflexivity is involved when we as interviewers attempt to look at a situation or a concept from various perspectives. A modified form of discourse analysis inspired by subject positioning was used to reflect on power relations in four different interview situations. The analyses indicate that reflection on the power relations can lead to other forms of understanding of the interviewee. The main conclusion that can be drawn from this study is that power relations are created within an interview situation and therefore it is important to be aware of dominant perspectives. Researchers and nurses face the challenge of constantly raising their level of consciousness about power relationships, and discursive reflexivity is one way of doing this. Thus, reflexivity is an important part of the qualitative research process.

Doing masculinity, not doing health? a qualitative study among dutch male employees about health beliefs and workplace physical activity

“…Thus, Tom's question to the interviewer about discussing intimate issues with men might or might not have been asked to a woman. Power relations are created within interview settings and therefore interviewers must be aware of dominant perspectives stemming from social locations such as maleness, whiteness, or education [45,59], but also from the interviewer's age and self-confidence [58], as our analysis confirms. Such reflexivity can lead to another form of understanding of the interviewee.…”

Fostering students’ socioscientific decision-making: exploring the effectiveness of an environmental science competition

“…Interpretation: The interviewee constitutes the central interest when using retrospective interviews. This participant-centered data collection can initiate a shift in power between the researcher and the participant (Aléx & Hammarström, 2008). This shift enables participants to elucidate their individual understandings, which enabled us to detect both understandings of decisionmaking (the systematic and the more cooperative one).…”

Conducting critical ethnography in long-term residential care: experiences of a novice researcher in the field

“…Power relations are present in all relationships, including reciprocal research relationships. A number of scholars have described the fluidity of power in qualitative research, such as CE and the influence of race, class and gender on this process (Tang 2002, Presser 2005), in particular during in‐depth, unstructured interviewing (Alex & Hammarstrom 2008, Maiter et al. 2008).…”