Should Photovoltaics Stay at Home? Comparative Life Cycle Environmental Assessment on Roof-Mounted and Ground-Mounted Photovoltaics

Abstract

Renewable energy technologies like photovoltaics may be considered an indispensable component of a low-carbon electricity mix, but social acceptance should not be taken for granted. For instance, in Greece there are still claims, especially in rural areas, regarding the land use and the competition against more traditional economic activities such as grazing. An argument in favor of confining to roof-mounted photovoltaic installations is the additional infrastructure requirements for ground-mounted larger-scale photovoltaics. These requirements reduce and could potentially negate their environmental benefits. The aim of this study is to investigate the life cycle environmental impacts of commercial ground-mounted photovoltaic farms and compare them against residential roof-mounted photovoltaic installations. Data were gathered for a 500 kW ground-mounted photovoltaic installation and for five roof-mounted installations of 10 kW capacity, each from the same area at the prefecture of Pella in Northern Greece. An LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) was performed and results show that panel production is the main contributor for both types and that ground-mounted photovoltaics—when no transmission/distribution infrastructure is considered—have lower impacts than the roof-mounted residential photovoltaic installations for all impact categories except terrestrial ecotoxicity. However, when located further than 10.22 km from grid connection, ground-mounted photovoltaics have higher impacts for almost all environmental impact categories.

Design of an Agrivoltaic System with Building Integrated Photovoltaics

“…(2) PV modules attached to a roof [22]; and (3) PV modules integrated in a roof (or a greenhouse roof) [23]. Agrivoltaic systems have been studied in multiple countries such as Germany, Japan, China, United States, France, Chile, and South Korea [14,[17][18][19].…”

“…The roof BIPV has three different classifications: (1) PV modules on a rooftop [21]; (2) PV modules attached to a roof [22]; and (3) PV modules integrated in a roof (or a greenhouse roof) [23]. PV modules on a rooftop (i.e., rooftop PVs) are traditional rooftop PVs taking 80% of the BIPV market [3].…”

Research on Influencing Factors of Cost Control of Centralized Photovoltaic Power Generation Project Based on DEMATEL-ISM

“…At present, the research on centralized photovoltaic power generation mainly focuses on the cost of electricity [5], benefit analysis and evaluation [6], power generation efficiency [7,8], carbon emission [9], environmental impact [10], and so on, and there is little research on the influencing factors and their mechanism of cost control in the whole life cycle of centralized photovoltaic power generation. Mustafa et al [11] identified the key factors that affect the implementation of photovoltaic power generation projects through multiple linear regression models (MLRMs) and rule-based decision support systems (RBDSSs).…”

Strategies for LEED-NC-Certified Projects in Germany and Results of Their Life Cycle Assessment

“…Each credit can have a certain number of points. By adding up all these points, LEED projects can achieve one out of four certifications: certified (scores [40][41][42][43][44][45][46][47][48][49], silver (scores 50-59), gold (scores 60-79), or platinum (scores 80+) (Section 1.2 provides a summary of all prerequisites and credits for LEED-NC v3).…”