Should there be separate forensic psychiatry services for ethnic minority patients?

Across several countries (including the UK and U.S.) people of black (African-Caribbean) origin are overrepresented in secure psychiatric services. Risk assessment instruments for predicting violence are often used, but their accuracy is not known for ethnic minority patients. We therefore aimed: 1) to test the accuracy of two leading instruments (Violence Risk Appraisal Guide (VRAG) and HCR20 Risk Management Scheme) in patients from a black ethnic minority, and (2) to compare the levels of risk as defined by these instruments. Risk assessments were completed using only file information available at the time of discharge. Offending behavior postdischarge was obtained from official records with each patient being followed for at least 2 years. Both VRAG and HCR-20 were significant predictors of future violence for black patients, and had similar accuracy as when used on white patients. Risk assessment scores were slightly lower for black patients, but there were no significant differences in reconviction rates for either violent or general offences post discharge. The results provide an evidence base for the use of HCR-20 and VRAG as an accurate risk assessment instruments for black ethnic minority patients in the UK.

show abstract

Is anybody there? Supporting young people with psychosis

Day¹

2009

British Journal of School Nursing

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Should there be separate forensic psychiatry services for ethnic minority patients?

Cited by 3 publications

References 49 publications

Black communities, mental health and the criminal justice system

Black communities, mental health and the criminal justice system

Risk Assessment for Future Violence in Individuals from an Ethnic Minority Group

Is anybody there? Supporting young people with psychosis

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About