During meiotic prophase, the essential events of pairing, synapsis, and recombination are coordinated with meiotic progression to promote fidelity and prevent aneuploidy. The conserved AAA+ ATPase PCH-2 controls a variety of chromosome behaviors, including coordinating pairing, synapsis and recombination between homologous chromosomes to guarantee crossover assurance and accurate chromosome segregation. However, how PCH-2 accomplishes this coordination is poorly understood. Here, we use a combination of genetic, cytological, and biochemical analyses to show that PCH-2 regulates pairing, synapsis and recombination in C. elegans by remodeling meiotic HORMADs from a closed conformation to an unlocked conformation. Further, we find PCH-2 coordinates these events by distributing this regulation among the three essential meiotic HORMADs in C. elegans: PCH-2 acts through HTP-3 to regulate pairing and synapsis, HIM-3 to promote crossover assurance, and HTP-1 to control meiotic progression. In addition to identifying a molecular mechanism for how PCH-2 regulates interhomolog interactions, our results provide a possible explanation for the expansion of this family as a conserved evolutionary feature of meiosis. Taken together, our work demonstrates that PCH-2s well-characterized role in remodeling mitotic HORMADs applies to meiotic HORMADs and this remodeling coordinates homolog pairing, synapsis, recombination and meiotic progression to ensure accurate meiotic chromosome segregation.