Similarity-based anomaly score for fleet-based condition monitoring

Abstract

An increased number of industrial assets are monitored during their daily use, producing large amounts of data. This data allows us to better monitor the health status of these asset, enabling predictive maintenance to reduce risks and costs caused by unexpected machine failure. Many condition monitoring approaches focus on assessing a machine's health status individually. Often, these approaches require historical data sets or handcrafted fault indicators. However, multiple industrial applications involve monitoring multiple similar operating machines, a fleet. By assuming the healthy behavior for the majority of the machine, deviating signatures can indicate a machine fault.
 In this work, we extend our previous proposed framework for fleet-based condition monitoring (Hendrickx et al.). This framework uses interpretable machine learning techniques to automatically evaluate assets within a fleet while incorporating domain knowledge if available. It is designed with four building blocks. In the first block, the user defines a similarity measure to compare machines. This measure can be both data-driven as based on domain knowledge. The second block clusters the machines based on this similarity measure. The third block assesses the health status of a machine by assigning an anomaly score where higher scores represent more deviating behavior. Finally, each of these blocks is visualized in the fourth block to guide a domain expert to set up and gain trust in the framework.
 The anomaly score proposed in our previous work has two shortcomings. First, its value can change very abruptly; a slight deviation can cause a machine's anomaly score to change from very low to very high. Second, the score does not accurately represent the anomalousness of a machine. A machine with the highest anomaly score is not necessarily the most deviating. Finally, the anomaly score is assigned to a group of machines. It is thus hard to assess the health status of an individual machine. As a consequence, this anomaly score offers little insights into a machine's performance.
 The contribution of this paper is a new implementation of the anomaly score block. Instead of basing our anomaly score on the clustering, we make use of the machine's similarities within the fleet. This solves the shortcomings of the previous anomaly score and defines an individualized, continuous scoring mechanism that represents the anomalousness of a machine.
 
 Hendrickx, Kilian, et al. “A General Anomaly Detection Framework for Fleet-Based Condition Monitoring of Machines.” Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 139, Elsevier Ltd, 2019, p. 106585, doi:10.1016/j.ymssp.2019.106585.

Condition monitoring of wind turbines using machine learning based anomaly detection and statistical techniques for the extraction of 'healthy data'

“…The use of fleet information is not new, e.g. Beretta et al, (2020), Hendrickx et al (2020). The latter is most similar to our work.…”

“…2) By using CUSUM advantage is taken from the fact that the data are time series. This is not the case with the methodology in Hendrickx et al (2020).…”

“…This metric is robust for anomalies, but it also assumes that the majority of the wind turbines are healthy. The anomaly scores are not based on pairwise distances like in Hendrickx et al (2020), instead they are based on the cumulative difference between the fleet aggregate temperature and the wind turbine temperature. This has several advantages.…”

Using Data From Similar Systems for Data-Driven Condition Diagnosis and Prognosis of Engineering Systems: A Review and an Outline of Future Research Challenges

“…Only the load differs due to different load motors. Hendrickx et al [68] and Hendrickx et al [318] presented a similar approach for the same application. Among other approaches, Liu [71] performed time series cluster analysis with operational data from an onshore wind turbine farm comprising 24 turbines to establish an optimal maintenance schedule (F2).…”

PHM for Spacecraft Propulsion Systems: Similarity-Based Model and Physics-Inspired Features

“…This method analyses and clusters LED spectral data to identify the early indicators of degradation. Hendrickx et al (2020) enhance a fleet-based industrial asset monitoring framework by refining the anomaly scoring system with machine similarities within the fleet, permitting more precise, continuous, and individualized scoring that accurately pinpoints machine anomalies.…”