Simulated patients in undergraduate education in psychiatry

Abstract

This paper describes the use of simulated patients in medical education and how actors have been deployed with medical students in Aberdeen. The advantages and disadvantages of using actors for student education are summarised and we conclude with some possible future developments. At the outset, it may be helpful to outline some definitions, as in the review by Barrows (1993). A ‘standardised patient’ is an umbrella term for both an actual patient who is trained to present his or her own illness in a standardised way and also for a simulated patient who is a well person trained to portray an illness in a standardised way. This paper will use these terms but will relate mainly to the use of professional actors (not volunteers from the general public, who are often deployed by medical teachers) as simulated psychiatric patients.

Simulated versus traditional occupational therapy placements: A randomised controlled trial

“…Simulation has been shown to contribute positively to the education of students in a range of professions, including medicine (Brydges, Hatala, Zendejas, Erwin & Cook, 2015;Eagles, Calder, Wilson, Murdoch & Sclare, 2007), nursing (Bradley, 2006;Harder, 2009;Ricketts, 2011) and allied health (Mori, Carnahan & Herold, 2015;Yeung, Dubrowski & Carnahan, 2013). Occupational therapy literature also describes the benefits of simulation for training and education (Reed, 2014), although there is a paucity of rigorous evaluations (Bennett, Rodger, Fitzgerald & Gibson, 2017).…”

Comprehensive Training in Suspected Child Abuse and Neglect for Dental Students: A Hybrid Curriculum

“…The workshops teach students to use open-ended, nonthreatening questions that require a descriptive answer rather than just a yes or no answer and to conduct interviews without suggesting answers for the child or pressing the child for answers to questions the child is unwilling to answer. [28][29][30] The goal is to build critical thinking skills that help students determine if the child's explanation is consistent with the parent's.…”

‘Don't you have to care about people?’ The challenges of caring

“…Simulation, whether it is delivered in the form of roleplay or by using manikins, is predicated on the notion of acting; actors are at times employed in the guise of patients to teach a variety of lessons in education relating to such issues as ethics, medical error and disclosures of death. 5 Does this element of 'acting' introduce a false note into the doctor-patient relationship?…”

“…Problem‐based learning approaches use case studies to provoke students to assume the identity of the diagnosing doctor. Simulation, whether it is delivered in the form of role‐play or by using manikins, is predicated on the notion of acting; actors are at times employed in the guise of patients to teach a variety of lessons in education relating to such issues as ethics, medical error and disclosures of death …”