To help identify possible element stresses, seedling responses of Agave deserti to high concentrations of various elements were examined by monitoring both 12‐day growth in hydroponic solution and 6‐month growth in sand culture. In addition, nocturnal acid accumulation by adult plants of six agave species was related to element levels in their chlorenchyma. Compared with common agronomic plants, seedlings of A. deserti were quite sensitive to salinity, with 50 mm NaCl greatly reducing root elongation in hydroponic solution and watering with 25 mm NaCl preventing growth in sand culture. The seedlings were rather insensitive to Ca concentrations from 0.2 to 5 mm and to pH from pH 5 to 8. They also tolerated high levels of B and of the heavy metals Cu and Zn. Nocturnal acid accumulation by adult plants of the six agave species was positively correlated with levels of 10 elements in the chlorenchyma, especially N (r2 = 0. 70), B (r2 = 0.51), and Ca (r2 = 0.46). In contrast, nocturnal acid accumulation was weakly and negatively correlated with chlorenchyma Na (r2 = 0.13), consistent with the deleterious effects of salinity on the growth of seedlings. Correlations between nocturnal acid accumulation and element content were consistent with previous fertilizer experiments with N, B, Ca, K, and P on A. sisalana. Element levels in the chlorenchyma of the six agave species were generally similar to those of previously studied cacti, including a low Na and high Ca level compared with agronomic plants.