Simulation Study of Rear-End Crash Evaluation considering Driver Experience Heterogeneity in the Framework of Three-Phase Traffic Theory

Abstract

Driving safety is considered to have a strong relationship with traffic flow characteristics. However, very few studies have addressed the safety impacts in the three-phase traffic theory that has been demonstrated to be an advancement in explaining the empirical features of traffic flow. Another important issue affecting safety is driver experience heterogeneity, especially in developing countries experiencing a dramatic growth in the number of novice drivers. Thus, the primary objective of the current study is to develop a microsimulation environment for evaluating safety performance considering the presence of novice drivers in the framework of three-phase theory. First, a car-following model is developed by incorporating human physiological factors into the classical Intelligent Driver Model (IDM). Moreover, a surrogate safety measure based on the integration concept is modified to evaluate rear-end crashes in terms of probability and severity simultaneously. Based on a vehicle-mounted experiment, the field data of car-following behavior are collected by dividing the subjects into a novice group and an experienced group. These data are used to calibrate the proposed car-following model to explain driver experience heterogeneity. The results indicate that our simulation environment is capable of reproducing the three-phase theory, and the changes in the modified surrogate safety measure are highly correlated with traffic phases. We also discover that the presence of novice drivers leads to different safety performance outcomes across various traffic phases. The effect of driver experience heterogeneity is found to increase the probability of the rear-end crashes as well as the corresponding severity. The results of this study are expected to provide a scientific understanding of the mechanisms of crash occurrences and to provide application suggestions for improving traffic safety performance.

Surrogate safety evaluation of curve sections on an interurban highway under heterogeneous traffic conditions in India

“…The parameters are validated using the crash data at different intersections. Yang et al [5] applied microsimulation in their study for evaluating safety performance of a novice drivers and developed an Intelligent Driver Model (IDM) by incorporating human physiological factors and surrogate safety measures.…”

Exploring the Spatiotemporal Characteristics and Causes of Rear-End Collisions on Urban Roadways

“…The data are analyzed by algorithms and models to derive the effects of different human factors on crashes. Driver's risk reaction time [28], speed and surroundings perception [29], sleep deprivation [30], driver's experience [31] and driver's intention [32] are often used as research objects.…”

Heterogeneity Analysis of Operating Mode Distribution for Modeling Energy Consumption of Light-Duty Vehicles

“…Research into inter-heterogeneity is more popular in road congestion analysis and driving safety analysis. Chiabaut et al ( 5 ) found that mean jam spacing corresponds to the arithmetic mean of individual jam spacing, and the effect of driver behavior heterogeneity was found to increase the probability of rear-end crashes as well as the corresponding severity ( 10 ). However, there are few studies on the heterogeneity of driving behavior leading to errors of energy consumption estimation.…”