A series of laboratory experiments was conducted at the University of Wyoming to determine the steamflood recovery mechanisms for the Asphalt Ridge Tar Sands deposit located near Vernal, Utah. Steam at various temperatures and qualities, hot water and also nitrogen were injected into an adiabatic tube containing the tar sands, and the recovery curves were measured. From the results of the experiments, it was concluded that the Asphalt Ridge steamflood mechanisms consist of viscosity reduction, solvent extraction-enrichment, liquid displacement, and steam distillation. In addition to determining the steamflood mechanisms, it was also shown that, for the Asphalt Ridge Tar Sands (1) steam injection recovered more oil than did a hot waterflood at the same temperature (2) thick, viscous oil was produced during low quality steam runs, whereas a lighter oil has produced at higher qualities, and (3) intermediate quality steam will recover more of the original oil in place than will either high quality steam or hot water.
Introduction
Among the so-called alternate sources of energy which have been and are being examined by various grouts within the U.S. are the tar sands deposits which lie in eastern and southern Utah. The Laramie Energy Technology Center of the U.S. Department of Energy has conducted two field tests of in situ combustion and one test of steam injection in the N.W. Asphalt Ridge deposit near Vernal, Utah, the results which have previously presented. In conjunction with these tests presented. In conjunction with these tests a number of experimental and numerical studies have been performed to help predict and evaluate the results of these tests. This paper reports the results of a laboratory investigation of the mechanisms involved in the recovery of the Asphalt Ridge bitumen by injection of steam.
In general the bitumen from tar sands of Utah exhibits a viscosity over an order of magnitude higher than that of similar materials from Canada, as shown by Fig. 1. This makes the problem, of mobilization somewhat more difficult, although it is expected that the same type of in situ processes that work in northern Alberta will be processes that work in northern Alberta will be applicable in eastern Utah. However it is necessary to attempt to quantify the similarity and determine what the design parameters are for the different resources.
The strategy employed in the current set of experiments was suggested by the classic work of Willman, et. al.. Possible mechanisms of recovery were identified and experiments were then devised to test for the individual presence and effectiveness of these component mechanisms. The effects of temperature and steam quality on recovery were also examined.
Theory
In 1961, Willman et. al. experimentally showed that the following mechanisms were present in the displacement of conventional heavy crude oil by steam:viscosity reduction due to increase in temperature,thermal swelling of the oil,steam distillation,solvent extraction, andgas drive effects.
Johnson, et. al. later confirmed the importance of vaporization mechanism in the recovery of oil by steam displacement.
Although the above studies contributed significantly to our understanding of the steam displacement process, that were conducted on conventional heavy crudes and used 100% steam quality. Thus, work was needed to check the results with the bitumen type hydrocarbon found in tar sand deposits.
The Canadian deposits have been studied fairly extensively. Among the steam work performed was that reported by Ehrlich. performed was that reported by Ehrlich.