Label-free proteomics by data-dependent acquisition (DDA) enables the unbiased quantification of thousands of proteins, however it notoriously suffers from high rates of missing values, thus prohibiting consistent protein quantification across large sample cohorts. To solve this, we here present IceR, an efficient and user-friendly quantification workflow that combines high identification rates of DDA with low missing value rates similar to DIA. Specifically, IceR uses ion current information in DDA data for a hybrid peptide identification propagation (PIP) approach with superior quantification precision, accuracy, reliability and data completeness compared to other quantitative workflows. We demonstrate greatly improved quantification sensitivity on published plasma and single-cell proteomics data, enhancing the number of reliably quantified proteins, improving discriminability between single-cell populations, and allowing reconstruction of a developmental trajectory. IceR will be useful to improve performance of large scale global as well as low-input proteomics applications, facilitated by its availability as an easy-to-use R-package.