Single grade specialist training in otolaryngology – a survey of attitudes among present and recent trainees

Abstract

The authors present the results of a postal questionnaire about possible advantages, disadvantages, and logistics of a single grade training scheme. Replies were received from 13 recently appointed consultants and 42 otolaryngologists in training. The majority (43) were in favour of a single grade training scheme, although it was felt that certain potential problems would need to be carefully addressed, particularly the potential for narrow clinical exposure and the difficulties inherent in early selection for higher surgical training. It was also felt that for such schemes to work, considerable extra consultant time would need to be set aside purely for teaching. The respondents' ideal training scheme is outlined.

Operative training in otolaryngology in the United Kingdom: A specialist registrar survey

“…A total of 142 valid e-mail addresses were used, resulting in 61 responses (43 per cent reply rate -representing 32 per cent of all registrar posts). The reply rate was mediocre, however it was comparable to that in similar studies performed in the past -namely 30 per cent, 6 39 per cent 8 and 49 per cent. 9 The recording of the number of operations performed was based on self-reporting by trainees; however, their accounts correlate well with figures derived from trainees' logbooks.…”

Structured training of ENT Specialist Registrars in the out-patient clinic and theatre

“…The target group would have been contacted twice in a period of 18 months. Two similar studies have had responses of 39% and 46% 12,13 . It is possible to make some comments on the findings.…”

Work force planning: will the aspirations of the present group of Otolaryngology Specialist Registrars meet the need?

“…Historically trainees tend to view wholesale changes in training schemes with trepidation 2 . The majority (72%) of responding Otolaryngology SpR's expressed a desire to pursue a sub‐speciality interest within Otolaryngology as a consultant.…”