Posterior dislocation is a rather rare injury, often misdiagnosed. The current report offers valuable insights regarding the anatomical background of this clinical entity and emphasizes the 'light-bulb sign,' which can be observed in anterior-posterior shoulder X-rays when there is a posterior dislocation. It is crucial for healthcare professionals, including emergency department physicians, radiologists, general practitioners, orthopedic surgeons, and other relevant medical experts, to be well-acquainted with this sign and maintain a heightened awareness when encountering such cases. A 57-year-old male presented to the Emergency Department due to right shoulder pain immediately after an epileptic seizure. His arm was locked in internal rotation, while the initial X-rays, although did not reveal evident malalignment, showed the light-bulb sign. Further imaging with a computer tomography (CT) scan exhibited a large (50%) reverse Hill-Sachs defect. The patient was treated surgically with hemiarthroplasty. The light-bulb sign should be a red flag for physicians who evaluate these patients or these X-rays. The patient's history, such as epileptic seizures and examination, especially the locked arm in internal rotation, are of paramount importance for not misdiagnosing these cases.