The pyrrolysine tRNA synthetase-tRNA pair is probably one of the most promiscuous tRNA-synthetase pairs found in nature, capable of genetically encoding a plethora of noncanonical amino acids through stop codon reassignment. Proteins containing reactive handles, post-translational modification mimics or both can be produced in practical quantities, allowing inter alia the probing of biological pathways, generating antibody-drug conjugates and enhancing protein function. This Minireview summarises the development of pyrrolysine amber stop-codon suppression, presents some of the considerations required to utilise this technique to its greatest potential, and showcases the creative ways in which this technique has led to a better understanding of biological systems.