Skin pigmentation, self-perceived color, and arterial blood pressure in Puerto Rico

Abstract

Darker skin color has been associated with higher average blood pressure in several African-derived populations in the Americas. This pattern has been interpreted as evidence of genetic, physiologic, or sociocultural mechanisms, but existing evidence does not provide an adequate means of evaluating these alternatives. This paper introduces a measurement strategy to isolate the cultural and biological dimensions of skin color, and it develops a specific hypothesis regarding the cultural significance of skin color in Puerto Rico and its relationship to arterial blood pressure. Data come from a face-to-face survey in southeastern Puerto Rico (N = 100). There is no association between blood pressure and skin pigmentation, as measured by reflectance spectrophotometry. However, the discrepancy between self-perceived color and skin pigmentation, a measure we call "color incongruity," is associated with systolic blood pressure (SBP) through an interaction with socioeconomic status (SES) (P = 0.009). For low-SES respondents, darker self-ratings of color relative to skin pigmentation are associated with higher mean SBP. For high-SES respondents, however, darker self-ratings of color relative to pigmentation are associated with lower mean SBP. We interpret this pattern as evidence that the relationship between skin color and blood pressure is mediated by sociocultural processes, and we highlight the need for testable hypotheses and appropriate measurement operations in research on racial inequalities in health.

The relationship between European genetic admixture and body composition among Hispanics and Native Americans

“…It is difficult to determine the extent to which differences in health-related phenotypes between various US ethnic groups are driven by the genetic differences between those groups, because genetic and environmental differences tend to co-vary (Burchard et al, 2003;Foster and Sharp, 2002;Gravlee and Dressler, 2005;Paradies et al, 2007;Risch, 2006). From a medical genetics perspective, it is important to elucidate the effects of both genetic and environmental factors on health (Foster and Sharp, 2002;Sankar, 2006).…”

A critical review of racial/ethnic variables in osteoporosis and bone density research

“…For example, Gravelee and colleagues have investigated the link between arterial blood pressure and skin color, illustrating that stresses associated with cultural perceptions of racial and ethnic identity can influence health status, independently of genetic factors [20,21]. Eliminating racial/ethnic categories as variables, however, is not the answer and would seriously hinder efforts to document and reduce racial health disparities that are quite common in the USA.…”

BMI, income, and social capital in a native Amazonian society: Interaction between relative and community variables

“…Anthropologists have found that cultural dissonance, stress, and objective indicators of health, such as blood pressure, move in unison (Dressler, 2004;Dressler and Bindon, 2000;Gravlee and Dressler, 2005;McDade, 2002;McDade et al, 2000). In recent work, Dressler, McDade, and Gravlee use cultural consensus and status incongruity models to show that people in Brazil, Samoa, and the USA (including Puerto Rico) who diverge from cultural norms of health, sociability, and status suffer from worse objective health (e.g., blood pressure) than people closer to the cultural norm.…”