“…Our present interest in PP i stems from comparative physiological investigations into the energetics of primordial metabolism (Martin and Russell, 2007;Sousa et al, 2013;Sousa and Martin, 2014;Preiner et al, 2020). We reasoned that if PP i had played any role in primordial energetics, as is widely assumed (de Duve, 1991;Russell et al, 2013Russell et al, , 2014Wang et al, 2019;Piast et al, 2020), evidence for that role should be preserved in the conserved core of metabolism within modern cells. This is the same conventional logic that is used to interpret other aspects of physiology as relicts of ancient metabolism: metal sulfide clusters in proteins (Eck and Dayhoff, 1966;Wächtershäuser, 1992;Heinen and Lauwers, 1997), the use of organic cofactors as catalysts (White, 1976), carbon metal bonds in enzyme active sites (Martin, 2019), thioesters as energy currencies (Semenov et al, 2016;Kitadai et al, 2021), or anaerobic chemolithoautotrophy (Mereschkowsky, 1910;Decker et al, 1970).…”