Small Food Stores and Availability of Nutritious Foods: A Comparison of Database and In-Store Measures, Northern California, 2009

Abstract

IntroductionSmall food stores are prevalent in urban neighborhoods, but the availability of nutritious food at such stores is not well known. The objective of this study was to determine whether data from 3 sources would yield a single, homogenous, healthful food store category that can be used to accurately characterize community nutrition environments for public health research.MethodsWe conducted in-store surveys in 2009 on store type and the availability of nutritious food in a sample of nonchain food stores (n = 102) in 6 predominantly urban counties in Northern California (Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin, Sacramento, San Francisco, and Santa Clara). We compared survey results with commercial database information and neighborhood sociodemographic data by using independent sample t tests and classification and regression trees.ResultsSampled small food stores yielded a heterogeneous group of stores in terms of store type and nutritious food options. Most stores were identified as convenience (54%) or specialty stores (22%); others were small grocery stores (19%) and large grocery stores (5%). Convenience and specialty stores were smaller and carried fewer nutritious and fresh food items. The availability of nutritious food and produce was better in stores in neighborhoods that had a higher percentage of white residents and a lower population density but did not differ significantly by neighborhood income.ConclusionCommercial databases alone may not adequately categorize small food stores and the availability of nutritious foods. Alternative measures are needed to more accurately inform research and policies that seek to address disparities in diet-related health conditions.

The relationship of the local food environment with obesity: A systematic review of methods, study quality, and results

“…Similarly, studies have found that the availability of convenience stores increases the walkability of a neighborhood , which has been associated with lower obesity . Additionally, there is evidence that access to unhealthy foods is ubiquitous in the US , making it impossible to see differences in associations with obesity at current exposure levels.…”

Do adolescents who live or go to school near fast-food restaurants eat more frequently from fast-food restaurants?

“…The main weakness of Business Analyst identified by Forsyth et al (2010) was in coding businesses by type, but as the study team coded fast food restaurants using names this issue was minimized. Others have pointed out that fieldwork is superior to commercial business databases in assessing the nutrition level of food in food stores (such as convenience and grocery stores) where availability of different food types varies across stores (Kersten et al, 2012). This is also a problem with restaurants, though in the case of fast food restaurants there is presumably more uniformity of food types across facilities.…”

Convenience stores are the key food environment influence on nutrients available from household food supplies in Texas Border Colonias

“…Smaller community and neighborhood retail food venues may exert a greater influence on the acquisition of household food supplies [15,16], especially for limited resource families in rural/underserved areas [3,17]. Neighborhood food stores, such as convenience stores, are ubiquitous, smaller in size and carry fewer fresh and healthier food items [3,18-20]. …”