Social Cognitive Theory: The Antecedents and Effects of Ethical Climate Fit on Organizational Attitudes of Corporate Accounting Professionals—A Reflection of Client Narcissism and Fraud Attitude Risk

Abstract

The rash of high-profile accounting frauds involving internal corporate accountants calls into question the individual accountant's perceptions of the ethical climate within their organization and the limits to which these professionals will tolerate unethical behavior and/or accept it as the norm. This study uses social cognitive theory to examine the antecedents of individual corporate accountant's perceived personal fit with their organization's ethical climate and empirically tests how these factors impact organizational attitudes. A survey was completed by 203 corporate accountants to assess their perception of relevant variables. The results of the structural equation model indicate three significant antecedents relating to ethical climate fit: higher internal levels of locus of control; greater numbers of prior job changes; and higher perceptions of an increasingly better fit with the firm's ethical climate (e.g., fit trend). Our results also indicate that higher levels of perceived fit to the ethical climate of a firm are associated with higher levels of perceived job satisfaction and organizational commitment. We also theorize that perceptions of an organization's ethical climate may be reflections of client narcissism and serve a potential indicator of fraud risk. This is an important topic of study, since current auditing standards call for auditors to examine organizational attitudes toward fraud, but offer minimal guidance in doing so.

The Deliberate Engagement of Narcissistic CEOs in Earnings Management

“…This supports the notion that CEO narcissism potentially weakens control by the board (Zhu and Chen 2015b). In a nutshell, the literature theoretically proposes that narcissistic CEOs identify with the company they lead, and use accounting measures to gain the admiration of their share-and other stakeholders, which can also result in organizational misbehavior including accounting fraud or stock price manipulation (Amernic and Craig 2010;Anderson and Tirrell 2004;Domino et al 2015;Harrison et al 2016). Supporting this view Marquez-Illescas et al (2018) find that qualitative disclosures in firms with narcissistic leaders are biased upward.…”

Changing the focus of locus (of control): A targeted review of the locus of control literature and agenda for future research

“…Wang et al, 2010) and organizational trust (Lilly & Virick, 2006). In a recent study involving corporate accountants, internal locus of control was also positively related to ethical climate fit, which in turn positively related to organizational commitment (Domino, Wingreen, & Blanton, 2015).…”

Association between ethical leadership, ethical climate and organizational citizenship behavior from nurses’ perspective: a descriptive correlational study

“…Social cognitive theory (SCT) suggests that one's beliefs and motivations are formed on valuable Judgments [33,34]. SCT is used as a theoretical underpinning to improve the understanding of the relationships between EL, EC and OCB.…”