Social countermarketing: brave new world, brave new map

Abstract

Purpose -Conceptual advancement underpins the progress of social marketing and countermarketing research but has been neglected in recent years. This paper aims to describe a new integrative framework of social countermarketing (SCM) concepts, techniques and defining characteristics, based on research tracing the conceptual evolution of the field and contrasting commercial (profit-focused) and social (public good-focused) countermarketing.Design/methodology/approach -This paper undertook searches of electronic databases to examine how socially oriented countermarketing has been characterised in the research literature. Search terms included "countermarketing", "critical marketing", "de-marketing" and "counter-advertising". Broad inclusion criteria allowed consideration of reports, conference and media outputs, as well as peer-reviewed articles published since 1971. Selected marketing journals were searched individually.Findings -After screening of 408 initial search results, 80 studies were retained and full papers retrieved.Main ideas, definitions, scope, concepts and terms used were mapped to identify the common and distinguishing features, as well as higher-order organising themes. This led to the development of a new conceptual framework for SCM comprising eight domains.Research limitations/implications -The integrative conceptual framework offers a foundation for future research and SCM practice.Originality/value -This paper introduces a framework designed to advance the conceptual basis of SCM research and practice with particular reference to the field of public health and disease prevention.

Exploring Mistakes and Failures in Social Marketing: The Inside Story

“…There is also anecdotal evidence in the form of case studies that social marketers are indeed engaging with the priority group in the process of co-creation (Biroscak, 2017; Blanchette et al, 2016; Erickson et al, 2015). Nevertheless, this research adds to the literature suggesting that top-down approaches are still common when it comes to the way that social marketers engage with the priority group from the research to the evaluation stage of programming (Bellew et al, 2017; Dietrich et al, 2016; McBride et al, 2000; Vogl, 2007).…”

Junk Food Marketing on Instagram: Content Analysis

“…Brands are using social media platforms such as Instagram to advertise to a growing number of consumers, with little to no restrictions. Public health bodies need to act to develop compelling social counter-marketing campaigns as a way of combating this advertising [ 39 ]. This study also contributes to the growing evidence of the urgent need to establish policy action regarding ENDP food and beverage advertising [ 40 ] that is reflective of the current media environment.…”

Live and trending: the next step for public health campaigns?

“…16 As real-time advertising opportunities become increasingly engaging and difficult to regulate, the public health sector needs to use, and trial dedicating resources to, these same platforms to launch effective social counter-marketing campaigns. 15 …”

“…Besides Facebook Live feeds, there are additional innovative real-time social media avenues requiring human resources that public health campaigns can use to effectively disseminate public health messages to a large and engaged audience, such as Instagram stories, Periscope or Snapchat. Social media marketing staff members can dedicate the time and strategic thinking required to develop and implement successful social counter-marketing for health promotion 15 to operate in a space that is currently saturated by companies advertising processed and discretionary food and beverages.…”