Social Determinants of Health: Underreported Heterogeneity in Systematic Reviews of Caregiver Interventions

Abstract

Background and Objectives Although most people have some experience as caregivers, the nature and context of care are highly variable. Caregiving, socioeconomic factors, and health are all interrelated. For these reasons, caregiver interventions must consider these factors. This review examines the degree to which caregiver intervention research has reported and considered social determinants of health. Research Design and Methods We examined published systematic reviews and meta-analyses of interventions for older adults with age-related chronic conditions using the PRISMA and AMSTAR 2 checklists. From 2,707 papers meeting search criteria, we identified 197 potentially relevant systematic reviews, and selected 33 for the final analysis. Results We found scant information on the inclusion of social determinants; the papers lacked specificity regarding race/ethnicity, gender, sexual identity, socioeconomic status, and geographic location. The majority of studies focused on dementia, with other conditions common in later life vastly underrepresented. Discussion and Implications Significant gaps in evidence persist, particularly for interventions targeting diverse conditions and populations. To advance health equity and improve the effectiveness of interventions, research should address caregiver heterogeneity and improve assessment, support, and instruction for diverse populations. Research must identify aspects of heterogeneity that matter in intervention design, while recognizing opportunities for common elements and strategies.

Psychological Well-Being Among Informal Caregivers in the Canadian Longitudinal Study on Aging: Why the Location of Care Matters

“…The findings of this study have important implications for policy and practice. In particular, they contribute to a growing body of evidence suggesting the need for tailored interventions that take into account the heterogeneity of caregiving ( Young et al, 2020 ). This includes aspects of the caregiving context such as the location of the care provided as well as the gender of the caregiver.…”

“…One key to reconciling caregiving stress and caregiving rewards perspectives may be through a focus on the caregiving context such as the location of caregiving. The caregiving context usually references factors such as geographic setting, community resources, living situation/proximity, and financial resources and characteristics ( Young et al, 2020 ). Our study focuses on the primary location of care, based on the view that “(t)he site where care occurs influences how care practices are shaped and experienced …” ( Torgé, 2020 , p. 378).…”

2021 Alzheimer's disease facts and figures

“…Improved tools and measures to personalize services for caregivers to maximize their benefits represent an emerging area of research 502–507 . More studies are also needed to adapt proven interventions or develop new intervention approaches for families from different racial, ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds and in different geographic settings (see the Special Report) 508–514 . Additional research on interventions focused on disease stages is also required, as is research on specific intervention needs for LGBT caregivers 369…”

Emotional and Cognitive Empathy in Caregivers of People With Neurodegenerative Disease: Relationships With Caregiver Mental Health

“…In addition to these risk factors related to people with dementia, a number of demographic, financial, and social variables have also been linked to poor health in familial caregivers. Meta-analyses suggest that being (a) the spouse of a person with dementia, (b) a woman (i.e., experiencing sexism), (c) a member of a systemically oppressed race (i.e., experiencing racism), (d) low in socioeconomic status (i.e., having fewer resources, experiencing classism), and (e) more socially isolated are all associated with negative outcomes in caregivers (Brodaty & Donkin, 2009; Schulz et al, 1995; Young et al, 2020).…”