Social Identification with the Medical Profession in the Transition from Student to Practitioner

Abstract

Phenomenon: This study explores professional identity formation during a final year of medical school designed to ease the transition from student to practitioner. Although still part of the undergraduate curriculum, this "transitional year" gives trainees more clinical responsibilities than in earlier rotations. Trainees are no longer regarded as regular clerks but work in a unique position as "semi-physicians," performing similar tasks as a junior resident during extended rotations. Approach: We analyzed transcripts from interviews with 21 transitional-year medical trainees at University Medical Center Utrecht about workplace experiences that affect the development of professional identity. We used Social Identity Approach as a lens for analysis. This is a theoretical approach from social psychology that explores how group memberships constitute an important component of individual selfconcepts in a process called 'social identification.' The transcripts were analyzed using thematic analysis, with a focus on how three dimensions of social identification with the professional group emerge in the context of a transitional year: cognitive centrality (the prominence of the group for self-definition), in-group affect (positivity of feelings associated with group membership) and in-group ties (perception of fit and ties with group members). Findings: Students were very aware of being a practitioner versus a student in the position of semi-physician and performing tasks successfully (i.e., cognitive centrality). Students experienced more continuity in patient care in transitional-year rotations than in previous clerkships and felt increased clinical responsibility. As a semi-physician they felt they could make a significant contribution to patient care. Students experienced a sense of pride and purpose when being more central to their patients' care (i.e., in-group affect). Finally, in extended rotations, the trainees became integrated into daily social routines with colleagues, and they had close contact with their supervisors who could confirm their fit with the group, giving them a sense of belonging (i.e., in-group ties). Insights: Using the threedimension model of social identification revealed how students come to identify with the social group of practitioners in the context of a transitional year with extended rotations, increased clinical responsibilities, and being in the position of a "semi-physician." These findings shed light on the identity transition from student to practitioner within such a curricular structure. KEYWORDS professional identity formation; transitions in training continuum; undergraduate medical education TEACHING AND LEARNING IN MEDICINE https://doi.

Vertical integration in medical education: the broader perspective

“…Van den Broek et al studied professional identity formation in a vertically integrated curriculum that builds up to a final year deliberately designed to have students experience the responsibilities of a junior doctor (called 'semiphysician') under supervision. The authors found support for the notion that this curricular structure fosters students' social identification with the community of doctors, and generates a genuine team-member sensation [26,27].…”

Why do medical residents prefer paternalistic decision making? An interview study

“…They related how their decision making was guided by their convictions about their role as a doctor in the decision-making process (beliefs). The strength of their convictions and the firmness with which they were expressed suggested to us that these convictions could be part of their professional identity as a doctor [40][41][42]. Residents not only expressed the conviction that they are responsible for providing the best treatment in each patient, they also expressed the positivist view that each patient has a correct diagnosis which needs to be uncovered to allow them to provide patients with the best evidence-based treatment.…”

Longitudinal training models for entrusting students with independent patient care?: A systematic review

“…During their longitudinal programme, students assumed the role of a physician, 39 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 , 52 experiencing ownership of patients. 50 , 51 , 52 , 53 , 54 , 55 Some students even felt they were the primary physician for their patients, 56 , 57 increasing their sense of responsibility for patient care. 40 , 50 Students felt that the responsibilities they bore for independently providing patient care were adequate for their level of training.…”