Social inequality in shadow education: The role of high-stakes testing

Abstract

Against the background of the worldwide expansion of shadow education, research shows that students from high socio-economic status (SES) backgrounds participate more in shadow education than students from disadvantaged SES backgrounds. We relate these social inequalities in shadow education participation to institutional features of educational systems. More specifically, we argue that the effect of socio-economic background on participation in shadow education will be stronger in countries characterized by high-stakes testing. Using data from the Programme for International Student Assessment for the year 2012 (PISA 2012), we show that higher SES students participate more in shadow education. For three out of four indicators of shadow education, this relationship is stronger in countries that are characterized by high-stakes testing but only when accounting for unobserved country differences.

Supplementary education and the coronavirus pandemic: Economic vitality, business spatiality and societal value in the private tuition industry during the first wave of Covid-19 in England

“…Geographers can no longer afford to ignore an industry that is spreading its tentacles around the globe and could usefully trace the role of diverse mechanisms that prompt growth in different global regions. This uneven geography matters because the industry is largely socially regressive, favouring those already best placed to succeed, especially in countries whose education systems are amenable to such interventions ( Entrich, 2021 , Zwier et al, 2021 ). Moreover, the industry cannot be ignored as it is intimately linked to state education, a subject long an object of geographic concern.…”

“…In contrast, the most addressed ethical question asked about private tuition focuses on who gets access to it. As a commercial service, access to supplementary education tends to favour higher socio-economic groups, especially in nations where performance is incentivised by academically-selective school systems and high-stake testing ( Entrich, 2021 , Zwier et al, 2021 ), as tuition is “much less about support to those who are in real need…and a lot more about maintaining competitive advantages within schools for students who are already successful ( Bray, 2020: 11 ). During the pandemic, need was differentiated as support from schools varied: “some are getting lots of support, some are getting virtually none” (Margaret-NT-M-NW).…”

Education as care labor: Expanding our lens on the work-life balance problem

“…That is per quarter. I don't even dare to add it all up…if my husband sees it…" -Sharley, an accountant with two kids Singapore is often mentioned with other East Asian countries as having, somewhat paradoxically, highly-regarded and well-resourced 'world-class' education systems and also large private 'shadow education' industries (Bray, 2017, Byun et al, 2018, Entrich, 2020, Zwier et al, 2020. Parents' widespread beliefs about the importance of school results and their duties as parents in supporting children's education, together with high academic demands that cannot be met solely in school nor by parents, have paved the way for a massive private tutoring industry (Jason, 2009, Tan, 2017.…”

Exploring the uncharted waters of educational mobility: The role of key skills

“…Research shows that the participation in so-called 'shadow education', i.e., extra out-of-school educational activities to improve one's school performance, increases strongly all over the world (Bray 2011;Mori and Baker 2010). Children from lower social strata participate less in shadow education than children from higher strata, and this relationship between social origin and participation in shadow education is stronger in countries with high-stakes tests, such as the Netherlands (Zwier et al 2021). Coleman (1988) introduced the concept of social capital to show the importance of social networks both within and outside the family to foster educational success.…”