Social Learning in the COVID-19 Pandemic: Community Establishments’ Closure Decisions Follow Those of Nearby Chain Establishments

Abstract

As conveners that bring various stakeholders into the same physical space, firms can powerfully influence the course of pandemics such as coronavirus disease 2019. Even when operating under government orders and health guidelines, firms have considerable discretion to keep their establishments open or closed during a pandemic. We examine the role of social learning in the exercise of this discretion at the establishment level. In particular, we evaluate how the closure decisions of chain establishments, which are associated with national brands, affect those of proximate, same-industry community establishments, which are independently owned or managed. We conduct these analyses using cell phone location tracking data on daily visits to 230,403 U.S.-based community establishments that are colocated with chain establishments affiliated with 319 national brands. We disentangle the effects of social learning from confounding factors by using an instrumental variables strategy that relies on local variation in community establishments’ exposure to closure decisions made by brands at the national level. Our results suggest that closing decisions of community establishments are affected by the decisions made by chain establishments; a community establishment is 3.5% more likely to be open on a given day if the proportion of nearby open chain establishments increases by one standard deviation. This paper was accepted by Olav Sorenson, organizations.

Business exit during the COVID-19 pandemic: Non-traditional measures in historical context

“…SafeGraph is a company that aggregates anonymized location data from numerous mobile device applications to provide insights about physical places. 12 The company temporarily made their micro-level data available to researchers and government agencies studying the impact of COVID-19, and a number of papers have used the data in studying the effects of COVID-19 (e.g., de Vaan et al, 2021 , Farboodi et al, 2021 ). The company links location data from roughly 45 million mobile devices to a registry of around 6 million points of interest nationwide to record, at a daily frequency, individual visits to these points of interest.…”

“… 14 The methodology outlined in Appendix B turns out to be similar in spirit to what is done in de Vaan et al (2021) when studying the spillover effects of store closure. …”

Mitigating the Spread of COVID-19: What are firms doing and what they need to do?

“…Second, COVID-19 has halted manufacturing, and demand for several items has decreased considerably. The food business, in particular, has seen an 80% to 100% drop in sales as a result of the lockdown (de Vaan et al, 2021). Third, cash inflows to merchants have abruptly slowed.…”

Epidemic control with endogenous treatment capability under popular discontent and social fatigue

“…The frequency of rotation is dependent upon the reaction time to the infection. De Vaan et al (2021) examine the role of social learning in firms exercising their discretion to keep their establishments open or closed during a pandemic. They suggest that decisions to close community establishments, which are independently owned or managed, are affected by the decisions made by chain establishments, which are associated with national brands.…”