Social meanings and understandings in patient-nurse interaction in the community practice setting: a grounded theory study

Abstract

BackgroundThe patient-nurse relationship is a traditional concern of healthcare research. However, patient-nurse interaction is under examined from a social perspective. Current research focuses mostly on specific contexts of care delivery and experience related to medical condition or illness, or to nurses’ speciality. Consequentially, this paper is about the social meanings and understandings at play within situated patient-nurse interaction in the community practice setting in a transforming healthcare service.MethodsGrounded theory methodology was used and the research process was characterised by principles of theoretical sensitivity and constant comparative analysis. The field of study was four health centres in the community. The participants were patients and nurses representative of those attending or working in the health centres and meeting there by scheduled appointment. Data collection methods were observations, informal interviews and semi-structured interviews.ResultsKey properties of ‘Being a good patient, being a good nurse’, ‘Institutional experiences’ and ‘Expectations about healthcare’ were associated with the construction of a category entitled ‘Experience’. Those key properties captured that in an evolving healthcare environment individuals continually re-constructed their reality of being a patient or nurse as they endeavoured to perform appropriately; articulation of past and present healthcare experiences was important in that process. Modus operandi in role as patient was influenced by past experiences in healthcare and by those in non-healthcare institutions in terms of engagement and involvement (or not) in interaction. Patients’ expectations about interaction in healthcare included some uncertainly as they strived to make sense of the changing roles and expertise of nurses and, differentiating between the roles and expertise of nurses and doctors.ConclusionsThe importance of social meanings and understandings in patient-nurse interaction is not fully apparent to nurses, but important in the patient experience. Seeking understanding from a social perspective makes a contribution to enhancing knowledge about patient-nurse interaction with subsequent impact on practice, in particular the development of the patient-nurse relationship. The implications are that the meanings and understandings patients and nurses generate from experiences beyond and within their situated interaction are pivotal to the development of their relationship in the transforming community healthcare environment.

The challenges of communicating research evidence in practice: perspectives from UK health visitors and practice nurses

“…Changes in healthcare policy such as a focus on multidisciplinary teams with specialisms, and more research and training opportunities, may alleviate some of the issues that led some of our participants to lack confidence in communicating evidence. However, research suggests that blurring of professional boundaries and job roles, which these reforms bring, can cause confusion for both patients and practitioners about what is expected from them [48,49]; thus potentially compounding health practitioners’ confidence issues.…”

When practice precedes theory – A mixed methods evaluation of students' learning experiences in an undergraduate study program in nursing

“…It can be assumed that learning approaches used in nursing education have significant implications for many aspects of nursing practice beyond purely didactic considerations. A teacher-centered learning technique that implies asymmetrical power relations between students and teachers might serve as a poor model for students future patientenurse interactions (Lasiter, 2014;Stoddart, 2012;Sweeney, 1986). A paradigm that emphasizes the notion that students are autonomous, capable people, who can assume responsibility for their own learning, resonates better with the philosophy of person centeredness.…”

A conjoint analysis of the communication preferences of registered nurses towards mechanically ventilated patients

“…The objective of nursing is realized in every patient encounter, and it is deeply rooted in the nurse‐patient interaction (Tejero, ). Nurse‐patient communication or interaction, defined as the “transmission of information and feelings, recognition of these feelings, and confirmation of the patient that these feelings have been recognized by nurses” (McCabe, ; Sheppard, ), is a dyadic process which entails an array of processes of engagement to draw individual meanings and understanding, making it a social encounter with required social values and understandings (Stoddart, ; Tejero, ). As the relational link between the nurse and the patient progresses, the nurse and the patient are no longer perceived as separate entities but as partners in the process (Tejero, ).…”