Social Protection in an Electorally Competitive Environment (1): The Politics of Productive Social Safety Nets (PSSN) in Tanzania

Abstract

Social protection has become a more important part of social service delivery in Tanzania over the last couple of decades. This paper analyses the politics behind the making and implementation of the Productive Social Safety Nets (PSSN), a cash transfer scheme that became part of a broader, existing scheme aimed at poverty reduction and rural development, TASAF I-III. We trace the interrelationship between the domestic policy process and the shifting influence of transnational ideas. We argue that the introduction of TASAF and later PSSN was strongly influenced by international trends, driven by a policy coalition of bureaucrats and development partners, but that it was sanctioned by the country's political elites, who at times used the programmes for electoral purposes. This happened for instance by influencing the scale and speed of PSSN's implementation prior to the national elections in 2015, despite a tradition of scepticism towards cash transfers within the ruling CCM party. Recently, President John Magufuli's more productivist ethos, emphasising the importance of work, poses a threat to the programmes' continuation. This may also reduce the targeting of the poorest of the poor, which constitutes a major element of PSSN as we know it.

Alternative routes to the institutionalisation of social transfers in sub-Saharan Africa: Political survival strategies and transnational policy coalitions

“…The peer-reviewed country papers were commissioned by the Effective States and Inclusive Development Research Centre: Ghana(Abdulai, 2019), Ethiopia(Lavers, 2019a), Kenya(Wanyama and McCord, 2017), Mozambique(Buur and Salimo, 2018), Rwanda(Lavers, 2019b), Tanzania(Jacob and Pedersen, 2018), Uganda(Hickey and Bukenya, 2016) and Zambia(Pruce and Hickey, 2019).…”

Introduction to Land, Rights and the Politics of Investments in Africa

“…Maybe this is due in part to the fact that, apart from a few, usually urban-based professional groups, in sub-Saharan Africa organized political action from below has rarely influenced national politics either directly or systematically (Rakner, 2011;Waal and Ibreck, 2013). To some extent the political settlement (Khan, 2010) and political survival literature (Whitfield et al, 2015) increasingly emphasizes the role of elections in allowing governments to stay in power and especially how elections may affect relations between ruling elites and local populations (Behuria et al, 2017;Jacob and Pedersen, 2018). These relations may be changing under the influence of repeated elections (Kjaer and Therkildsen, 2013), which are gradually forcing ruling politicians to vie for smallholders' support, regional constituencies and votes more generally.…”

The Politics of Social Protection in Eastern and Southern Africa

“…At the time of writing, an actual old-age pension scheme has not come into place. There are nevertheless indications that the speed and scale of implementation of the PSSN accelerated in 2015 (Jacob and Pedersen 2018), which again suggests that once the programme is in place, the government will see its instrumental value in the elections.…”