An ongoing debate exists in the literature regarding the reliability of attention bias to threats. The current study directly examined how the interaction between available attention resources, personality traits, and stimuli visual characteristics moderates attention bias to task-irrelevant threatening stimuli. To this end, the current study conducted a comprehensive series of four experiments in which an emotional modification of the perceptual load task was employed. Participants with high and low fear of spiders, as well as participants diagnosed with arachnophobia, performed the task under high and low perceptual loads while ignoring task-irrelevant distracting spiders. As expected, all participants, regardless of fear level, were affected to some extent by the threatening distracting spider pictures, known to evoke threat due to their evolutionary value. However, the results show that high fear and phobia groups exhibit consistent attention bias to threats, depending on the threat’s ecological value. The low fear groups, on the other hand, showed a similar but weaker attention bias to threat, only when attentional resources were available.These results deomstratethe variance in individuals’ capacity to inhibit distracting threats and focus on current goals.