Socio-ecological Model as a Framework for Overcoming Barriers and Challenges in Randomized Control Trials in Minority and Underserved Communities

Abstract

Background:Numerous barriers and challenges can hinder the successful enrollment and retention of study participants in clinical trials targeting minority populations. To conduct quality research, it is important to investigate these challenges, determine appropriate strategies that are evidence-based and continue seeking methods of improvement.Methods:In this paper, we report such experiences in a registered clinical trial in an underserved minority population in the Southern part of United States. This research study is a randomized double-blind controlled clinical trial that tests the efficacy of higher-strength as compared to low-strength/standard of care folic acid to prevent fetal body and brain size reduction in pregnant women who smoke. A unique approach in this socio-behavioral, genetic-epigenetic clinical trial is that we have adopted the socio-ecological model as a functional platform to effectively achieve and maintain high participant recruitment and retention rates.Results:We highlight the barriers we have encountered in our trial and describe how we have successfully applied the socio-ecological model to overcome these obstacles.Conclusions and Global Health Implications:Our positive experience will be of utility to other researchers globally. Our fi ndings have far-reaching implications as the socio-ecological model approach is adaptable to developed and developing regions and has the potential to increase recruitment and retention of hard-to-reach populations who are typically under-represented in clinical trials.

A pragmatic trial to improve adherence with scheduled appointments in an inner-city pain clinic by human phone calls in the patient's preferred language

“…We also previously showed that a comprehensive initiative to address language barriers can improve adherence with scheduled appointments[2], but the retrospective nature of our observational cohort again precluded causal inference. As part of a comprehensive complex socioecological model [41], we developed a conceptional framework with a credible causal model for health care disparities in chronic pain, elements of which we tested in our present prospective controlled randomized pragmatic trial:…”

Individual and community level determinants of short birth interval in Ethiopia: A multilevel analysis

“…The model asserts that human health behavior, the experience of short birth interval in the current study, is influenced at multiple levels within the social and physical environment, such as the individual-, household-, community-and societal/policy-level factors [22][23][24]. The framework also assumes that interactions between individuals and their environment are reciprocal, implying that individuals are influenced by their environment and the environment is influenced by individuals [25]. For instance, an individual woman's literacy status is affected by community-level female literacy and vice versa.…”

Hurt or Help? Understanding Intimate Partner Violence in the Context of Social Norms as Practised in Rural Areas

“…Similarly, Bronfenbrenner's (1979) ecological model also explains the various social systems in which human beings live as a series of layers. The ecological model posits that throughout the development of humans there is a reciprocal interaction of objects, humans and their environment (Salihu, Wilson, King, Marty & Whiteman, 2015). The interactions of different factors on the four levels (individual, relationship, political and societal) of social ecology could contribute to IPV.…”