Soil properties following borrow pit reclamation with insufficient topsoil amended with peat and biochar

Abstract

Disturbed sites, such as borrow pits and oil and natural gas well sites, require reclamation to restore and sustain levels of productivity similar to those prior to the disturbance. However, salvaged topsoil at many sites is often insufficient to meet the 80% topsoil replacement depth (TRD80) required for successful reclamation in western Canada. This 5‐year study evaluated soil responses to 50% topsoil replacement depth without organic amendment (TRD50) or amended with either peat (PTRD50) or biochar (BTRD50), relative to the TRD80 treatment (Control), following borrow pit reclamation at a disturbed boreal site near Cold Lake, Alberta, Canada. Amendments were applied once at rates calculated to raise the soil organic carbon (SOC) content in the TRD50 soil to a level equal to that in the TRD80 treatment. Results showed a 143%, 87%, and 116% increase in total Kjeldahl nitrogen concentration in the PTRD50 relative to the TRD80, TRD50, and BTRD50 treatments, respectively, while soil potassium (K) concentration was significantly greater for BTRD50 than PTRD50. Peat and biochar significantly increased SOC concentrations by 83% and 88%, respectively, relative to the mean of TRD80 and TRD50 treatments. Our results show that peat and biochar can improve soil properties of disturbed boreal sites reclaimed with insufficient salvaged topsoil to a level suitable for successful reclamation. This has important implications on the reclamation of a multitude of disturbed sites, in Canada and globally, that have insufficient volumes of salvaged topsoil needed for successful reclamation.

Revegetation of disturbed land reclaimed with suboptimal topsoil replacement depth and organic amendments

“…The superior performance of peat relative to biochar may be related to greater nitrogen availability and moisture retention properties of peat‐amended relative to biochar‐amended soil (Table 3), which likely resulted in faster tree growth for PTRD50 than BTRD50. Nawu et al (2023) reported high TKN concentration in suboptimal TRD amended with peat (PTRD50) compared to BTRD50 following reclamation in the same study.…”

“…Soil sampling and analysis were described in detail by Nawu et al (2023). Briefly, initial soil samples were collected in 2014 for baseline characterization before the start of the experiment (Table 1).…”