Soldiers drawn into politics? The influence of tactics in civil–military relations

Abstract

The tactical level has become increasingly important in the conduct of contemporary complex military operations. Yet, the potential impact that this tactical level may have on domestic civil -military relations has been neglected. In this article, we focus on mechanisms by which low-level soldiers have acquired an increasing importance in tactical operations and we suggest that this may influence civil -military relations in the future. We argue that two phenomena deserve particular attention. These mechanisms are not new but they have had new effects by making it possible for soldiers to influence politics in sometimes unforeseen ways: the first is the strategic corporal and the second is the expansion of ancillary tasks. Our contribution lies at the interface between military sociology and security studies and seeks to show how the tactical level of warfare has become a fundamental context in which civil -military relations are enacted. Exploring these dynamics is fundamental to understanding under what conditions soldiers may interact with other actors in complex operations.

Polish Territorial Defence Forces and Innovation during the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Assessment of the Potential of a Mixed-type Force in Non-military Crisis Response

“…27 In the post-Cold War security environment, this so-far rather conservative and cautious military culture of Western armed forces has indeed allowed growing flexibility reflected, for example, in the concept of the strategic corporal, which gives much more decisive power to lower-level commanders. 28 Still, the level of acceptance and encouragement of innovation in the military might be different from that of civilian organisations, and business ventures in particular. Keeping that in mind, let us now consider the Polish Territorial Defence Forces from the perspective of innovation.…”

Operational experiences, military role conceptions, and their influence on civil-military relations

“…40 By contrast, much less attention has been paid to the consequences of these ordinary tasks and roles for civilmilitary relations. 41 Examples of the latter are Eyal Ben-Ari and Eran-Jona Meyyal, who explore different kinds of military 'institutional logics', such as an anti-terror logic, one of border policing and humanitarian assistance, and how these influence the military's relations with local civilians. 42 Cornelia Baciu's work, too, highlights the importance of studying military activities and their ramifications for both the military's self-understanding and civil-military relations.…”

Figurations of Wounding: Soldiers’ Bodies, Authority, and the Militarisation of Everyday Life

“…Changing approaches to global geopolitics and warfare, as well as the neoliberalisation of cultural and political life, pose particular problems for governments and military organisations whose legitimacy and authority have historically been based on the unquestioned authority of the state and of the line of command (Seidler 2013;Hines et al 2014). In the United Kingdom there has been a perceived erosion of British values or "crisis of authority" (Kirwan 2013;Blencowe, Brigstocke, and Dawney 2013) and an increase in public criticism of the British military (McCartney 2010;Edmunds and Forster 2007;Ruffa, Dandeker, and Vennesson 2013). This crisis of consent and of the authority of the government-military complex led to the former Prime Minister Gordon Brown commissioning a report entitled "National Recognition of our Armed Forces" (Davies, Clark, and Sharp 2008).This argued that the Armed Forces should be actively supported and encouraged by the British public.…”