Serine proteinase protein inhibitors follow the standard mechanism of inhibition (Laskowski M Jr, Kato I, 1980, Annu Rev Biochem 49593‐626), whereby an enzyme‐catalyzed equilibrium between intact (I) and reactive‐site hydrolyzed inhibitor (I*) is reached. The hydrolysis constant, Khyd is defined as [I*]/[I]. Here, we explore the role of internal dynamics in the resynthesis of the scissile bond by comparing the internal mobility data of intact and cleaved inhibitors belonging to two different families. The inhibitors studied are recombinant Cucurbita maxima trypsin inhibitor III (rCMTI‐III; Mr 3 kDa) of the squash family and rCMTI‐V (Mr ∼ 7 kDa) of the potato I family. These two inhibitors have different binding loop‐scaffold interactions and different Khyd values—2.4 (CMTI‐III) and 9 (CMTI‐V)—at 25°C. The reactive‐site peptide bond (P1‐P'1) is that between Arg5 and Ile6 in CMTI‐III, and that between Lys44 and Asp45 in CMTI‐V. The order parameters (S2) of backbone NHs of uniformly 15N‐labeled rCMTI‐III and rCMTI‐III* were determined from measurements of 15N spin‐lattice and spin‐spin relaxation rates, and {1H}‐15N steady‐state heteronuclear Overhauser effects, using the model‐free formalism, and compared with the data reported previously for rCMTI‐V and rCMTI‐V*. The backbones of rCMTI‐III (〈S2〉 = 0.71) and rCMTI‐III* (〈S2) = 0.63) are more flexible than those of rCMTI‐V (〈S2〉 = 0.83) and rCMTI‐V* (〈S2) = 0.85). The binding loop residues, P4‐P1, in the two proteins show the following average order parameters: 0.57 (rCMTI‐III) and 0.44 (rCMTI‐III*); 0.70 (rCMTI‐V) and 0.40 (rCMTI‐V*). The P1′‐P4′ residues, on the other hand, are associated with (S2) values of 0.56 (rCMTI‐III) and 0.47 (rCMTI‐III*); and 0.73 (rCMTI‐V) and 0.83 (rCMTI‐V*). The newly formed C‐terminal (Pn residues) gains a smaller magnitude of flexibility in rCMTI‐III* due to the Cys3‐Cys20 crosslink. In contrast, the newly formed N‐terminal (Pn′ residues) becomes more flexible only in rCMTI‐III*, most likely due to lack of an interaction between the P1′ residue and the scaffold in rCMTI‐III. Thus, diminished flexibility gain of the Pn residues and, surprisingly, increased flexibility of the Pn′ residues seem to facilitate the resynthesis of the P1‐P1′ bond, leading to a lower Khyd value.