New epoxy-silica hybrid coatings were prepared by a dual process consisting of a sol-gel process using tetraethoxysilane (TEOS) or 3-glycidyloxypropyl trimethoxysilane (GPTMS) in the presence of hyperbranched poly(ethyleneimine) with ethoxysilyl groups at the chain ends (PEI-Si) followed by a homopolymerization of diglycidylether of bisphenol A (DGEBA) using 1-methylimidazole (1-MI) as anionic initiator. The influence of the amount of TEOS and GPTMS in the characteristics of the coating was examined. Thin transparent films were obtained and their morphology was observed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The hydrolytic condensation was confirmed by 29Si-NMR studies. Cage-like nanometric structures were formed in case of adding GPTMS and bigger silica particles on adding TEOS to the formulation. Thermal stability was evaluated by thermogravimetry and the scratch resistance properties were also investigated, showing an improvement in resistance to break and to detachment in all the coatings containing GPTMS. Polymer Journal as you recommended us.As you mentioned in your decision letter the main remark is that the novelty has not been stressed sufficiently. However, the general comments of the reviewers were not bad.We recognized that the redaction did not include the novelty until we reach the discussion part and therefore we have included in the new version your opinion and we have stressed the novelty achieved in our work from the beginning. We have also included some changes suggested by the reviewers. Thus, we hope you can go further with the acceptance of our paper in European Polymer Journal.Looking forward to hearing from you, I remain.
Cover LetterComments to the reviewers.Reviewer #1: Graphical abstract:It is not clear what the authors want to transmit in the graphical abstract. The paper is not directly addressing the application procedure of the coatings. The graphical abstract should be adapted to show more clearly the real work addressed in this paper.
We have changed completely the graphical abstracts and we hope that the new version clearly represent the work contained in the article
HighlightsThe highlights do not reflect the main findings / advances in this paper. They should be rewritten to show the key findings / novelty.
We have also changed and stressed the key findings
AbstractThe abstract needs to be revised. Does the TEOS / GPTMS affect the properties of the hyperbranched polymer? So yes, in which direction? The abstract should be more indicative of what the reader will find in the paper.
The abstract has been rewritten. The addition of TEOS does not affect the properties of the hyperbranched polymer, but the properties of the final hybrid thermoset. The addition of TEOS leads to the formation of bigger particles, quite different from the cage-like particles formed from PEI-Si and/or GPTMS. The addition of GPTMS produces an improvement in resistance to break and to detachment in all the coatings. The incorporation of GPTMS to TEOS containing formulations allowed to prepar...