“…Along this line, the reaction between 1 and PhCHO with a 1 : 4 molar ratio in CH 3 CN at 0 8C was investigated (Table 1). With a 5 mol % catalyst concentration relative to the aldehyde that is the most common level in various Sc(OTf) 3 catalyzed reactions, the yield was 80% (entry 1), a figure comparable with that obtained in aqueous media. [6] Upon gradual reduction of the catalyst concentration, it turned out that the yield was not significantly decreased until the 0.1 mol % level where an 82% yield was obtained (entry 2).…”