Some Considerations for Child Rights Impact Assessment (CRIAs) of Business

Abstract

With increasing international attention to business and human/child rights, the necessary next step must examine the monitoring of activities in order for the connection between business and child rights to be meaningful. Consequently, the essential question for this paper is whether business should use child rights impact assessments (CRIAs) and if so, what are some considerations in order to move forward? It is argued that the business must develop and carry out CRIAs in order to meet its due diligence obligations, and to identify and respond to potential and actual child rights impacts due to business activities. Business should use CRIAs as part of a broader process of supporting its organizational commitment to human rights. Other actors can also participate in this monitoring endeavour of business activities. This paper identifies some challenges and considerations of CRIAs in relation to business.

How Businesses Can Assess the Impacts of Their Charitable Activities on the Rights of Children and Youth

“…Often these social impacts are not selfevident, as another participant flagged, creating the need for impact assessment processes to explore and provide detail on how children and youth are particularly affected [66]. As children's rights become illuminated within the impact assessment process, businesses will be able to proactively make decisions that not only mitigate risk, but also adopt a child rights-based approach to promote positive conditions for young people to thrive [74]. Hence, actors concerned about human rights within and outside of business (e.g., not only the state government but also academia and non-government) must recognise and assess the impacts of business activities on children.…”

“…While states are categorised in international law as duty bearers in order to implement human rights, business has not been held accountable in international or national law and policies governing human rights [12,78,79]. Further actions are needed to support accountability, especially as the roles of government and business become increasingly complex in relation to human rights due to legal frameworks, multinational corporate enterprises, and other issues [74]. One participant noted the tension that exists between the state and corporations, concerning who has the responsibility and obligation for certain human rights and children's rights [68].…”

Children’s Rights in the Indonesian Oil Palm Industry: Improving Company Respect for the Rights of the Child

“…Companies are expected to respect children's rights by integrating children's rights considerations into their policies and procedures, especially into their ongoing risk assessment, impact assessment, due diligence, environmental management systems, and/or continuous improvement processes [28]. Companies should also periodically conduct stand-alone child rights impact assessments [66], in which the negative impacts of company activities specifically on children are identified and addressed, including all those issues that arise from the company's relationships with its business partners [83]. In doing this, companies learn to acknowledge impacted children as a distinct group of rights-holders and as active agents in society.…”