In this note I expose the reliability standards I share, and give examples of different reliability standards.
Contents1. On different reliability standards 1 2. Reviewing peer review system 7 References 91. On different reliability standards By 'reliability' I understand validity and novelty of results. This is closely related, but not the same, as clarity. This is independent of value and importance of results.Reliability standards in mathematics change. E.g. a long time ago, oral proof was considered as reliable. As proofs gradually became more complicated, there appeared the understanding (and then the rule) that only written proof can be considered to be reliable or not (and so could constitute a fair claim for a result).