The corrosion behavior of carbon steel X36 (CSX36) in solutions of soils collected from different areas linked to the main pipe network of a water distribution system in Jeddah City (Obhour Al Shamaliyah, Ob-Sh; Al Shateie, Sh; Al Safa, Sf; Al Samer, Sa; and Al Jameaah, Ja) at an ambient temperature (23 ± 1 °C) was studied. The corrosion behavior was monitored using various techniques, such as weight loss and electrochemical (open circuit potential [OCP]; electrochemical impedance spectroscopy; and potentiodynamic polarization) measurements. Visual and microscopic examinations of the surface morphology of the studied metals were evaluated and discussed. The corrosion rates in all the studied soil solutions decreased with an increase in the immersion period over 80 weeks. The corrosivity of the studied soils based on weight loss measurements followed the order Sh > Ja > Ob-Sh > Sa > Sf. The value of the OCP gradually shifted to more negative values, indicating a higher tendency to corrode. For the soil solutions studied, the Ecorr shifted to more negative values, indicating that the corrosion process was under cathodic control. The values of icorr and 1/Rp tended to increase as the soil resistivity decreased. Moreover, there was good consistency between the corrosivity order of the studied soil solution obtained from electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and PDP measurements in the following order: Ob-Sh > Sh > Ja > Sa > Sf. A comprehensive assessment of the soil corrosivity based on various soil variables revealed that soil solutions of Ob-Sh and Sh are extremely corrosive, while the rest of the soil solutions are noncorrosive.