Sources of variance in current sense of humor inventories: How much substance, how much method variance?

Abstract

The present study investigates the relationship of self-report inventories of "sense of humor" and behavioral measures of humor as well as their location in the Eysenckian PEN system. 110 male and female adults in the ages from 17 to 83 years answered the following inventories: SHRQ (Martin and Lefcourt 1984), SHQZ (Ziv 1981), SHQ-3 revised (Svebak 1993), CHS (Martin and Lefcourt 1983), MSHS (Thorson and Powell 1993), HIS (Bell, McGhee, and Duffey 1986), 3 WD-K (Ruch 1983), CPPT (Köhler and Ruch 1993), TDS (Murgatroyd, Rushton, Apter, and Ray 1978), STCI-T (Ruch, Freiss, andKöhler 1993), and EPQ-R (Eysenck, Eysenck, and Barrett 1985). Reliability of the humor scales is examined and convergent and discriminant validity of homologous scales of humor appreciation and humor creation is determined. Behavioral measures and self-report instruments yield only meager correlations. While humor appreciation and humor creation form distinct traits in the behavioral measures, they can not be validly discriminated in the self-reports. Factor analysis of self-report inventories yields that the sense of humor is composed of the two orthogonal dimensions of cheerfulness and seriousness.Extraversion is predictive of cheerfulness, low seriousness, and quantity of humor production. Psychoticism is associated with low seriousness, wit and quality of humor production. Finally, emotional stability correlates with cheerfulness. All in all, the general state of the art in the assessment of the sense of humor and its components appears to be far from being satisfactory. Sources of variance -2 -

Humorous TV ads and the 3WD: Evidence for generalizability of humour appreciation across media?

“…The findings on psychoticism, extraversion, and neuroticism were in line with prior findings: while correlations of humour appreciation to E and N were absent, psychoticism related negatively to the funniness of INC-RES (Köhler & Ruch 1996). These results replicate findings from prior studies for the 3WD and show that the same patterns can be found for humour appreciation in TV advertisements.…”

“…Psychoticism in Eysencks's view relates negatively to the funniness of incongruity resolution humour (e.g., Köhler & Ruch 1996). Extraversion predicts the liking of both structure factors, as well as the funniness of sexual humour (cf.…”

How does psychopathy relate to humor and laughter? Dispositions toward ridicule and being laughed at, the sense of humor, and psychopathic personality traits

“…For example, in the PEN model of personality, psychopaths are located on the Psychoticism-dimension (Eysenck & Eysenck 1976, 1978. In performance tests of humor creation, high P-scorers were found to be wittier than the low scorer (Köhler & Ruch, 1996). Pearson (1983) found higher P scorer among professional cartoonists, which could be interpreted as an indirect support for the notion of wittiness being associated with the psychopathy dimension.…”

Humor-based online positive psychology interventions: A randomized placebo-controlled long-term trial

“…While McGhee (2010b) proposed six humor skills (i.e., enjoyment of humor, laughter, verbal humor, humor in everyday life, laughing at yourself, humor under stress), psychometric studies (Köhler & Ruch, 1996;Müller & Ruch, 2011;Ruch & Carrell, 1998) show that these components mostly mark a strong factor of humor that typically unites "[…] enjoying humorous stimuli, finding humour in everyday life and even in one's own mishaps, enjoying cheerful interactions and telling jokes" (Ruch & Carrell, 1998;p. 555).…”